Welcome Home

Listen To the Oral Argument in Knife Rights’ NYC Gravity Knife Lawsuit

Oral Argument in the second appeal in our long-running Federal civil rights lawsuit against New York City and District Attorney Cyrus Vance, Jr. was held Thursday. The three-judge panel included two judges who sat on the first appeal which we won unanimously.

All three judges asked questions indicating they understood the case, which is always a good place from which to start. Plaintiffs’ attorney, Daniel Schmutter with Hartman & Winnicki, P.C., did a great job explaining how the District Court judge, in ruling against us, had fundamentally re-characterized the case in a way that did not reflect the case presented.

Click here to listen to the Oral Argument hearing.

The key issue in the case, as was explained by Schmutter, is that there is no way anyone can tell if their knife is legal and no way for them to determine that they will not be subject to arrest and criminal prosecution. Under the City’s vague and subjective “wrist flick test,” also referred to as the “functional test,” it is impossible to know what knives will be treated as legal. He reminded the judges of testimony from Assistant District Attorney Dan Rather, Jr,. who stated on the stand that a consumer could test a knife twice using the “wrist flick” maneuver in a retail store and if it did not open then it was not an illegal gravity knife. However, Rather also testified the he could be arrested immediately upon exiting if a New York City Police officer stopped that same customer and was able to “wrist flick” it open.

The City’s and District Attorney’s lawyers argued the same misleading and irrelevant positions as before. They carefully ignored the facts and this key issue of the case as demonstrated by Rather’s testimony. It was all smoke and mirrors. The reality is that nobody in New York can know that their knife is legal because the “wrist flick test” is indeterminate and variable between persons doing the test. It is therefore unconstitutionally void for vagueness.

A decision is likely six to nine months away. The decision in our first appeal took eight months.

Click here to review the full appeal record including Plaintiff’s Appeal Brief and the two Amicus Briefs in support.

Knife Rights is Rewriting Knife Law in America™
28 Bills Enacted in 20 States in 8 Years!

Be the first to know. Get the latest Knife Rights updates:

And, sign up for our FREE News Slice™ Newsletter for more news you need to know.

Knife Rights is making a difference!
Invest a modest sum in a Sharper Future™ to protect your tools and rights.


Views: 30

Reply to This

White River Knives

Latest Activity

John Bamford commented on Dennis Hibar's photo
2 hours ago
John Bamford left a comment for Joe Abernathy
2 hours ago

Glenn "Oz" Osborne replied to Glenn "Oz" Osborne's discussion Just came in the mail :-).. Blackjack Model 1-7 sub hilt Effingham IL. in the group Blackjack Knives. Older and Newer!
3 hours ago

Glenn "Oz" Osborne replied to Glenn "Oz" Osborne's discussion Just came in the mail :-).. Blackjack Model 1-7 sub hilt Effingham IL. in the group Blackjack Knives. Older and Newer!
3 hours ago
J.J. Smith III left a comment for Joe Abernathy
3 hours ago
Joe Abernathy is now a member of iKnife Collector
3 hours ago

Doug Ritter posted a discussion
5 hours ago
Dennis Hibar commented on Dennis Hibar's photo
6 hours ago
Dennis Hibar posted a photo
6 hours ago
George Humphrey left a comment for J.J. Smith III
6 hours ago
Chuck Parham posted a status
"Hi gang! I've been away for quite a while. Hope all is well here at Ikc. I'll be posting pics of additions to my collection."
9 hours ago
Don Schriver commented on Jan Carter's group Queen Cutlery & Friends
13 hours ago

Craig Henry commented on Fred Feightner's group Case Fans
15 hours ago

dead_left_knife_guy commented on J.J. Smith III's photo
17 hours ago
Ken Mundhenk left a comment for Glen R
18 hours ago
Old Guy commented on Fred Feightner's group Case Fans
19 hours ago

Reed Cutlery Company

Visit Lee' s Cutlery

gear2survive !


Now Available


Click to view more

JSR Sports!


© 2018   Created by Jan Carter.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service