iKnife Collector
The online community of knife collectors, A Knife Family Forged in Steel
TOPS Knife Reviews
TOPS Knife Reviews
(as posted originally in the TOPS Group)
In this discussion forum, we'll be reviewing a variety of Tops knives. As one of the leading knife manufacturers in the US, Tops produces a HUGE variety of knives. Manufactured in Idaho, the Tops products are high-quality and their 1095 blades represent the epitome of modern blade craft. In this forum, we'll discuss the good, the bad and when applicable, we'll suggest changes. Enjoy!
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Jan Carter on
-
Reply by Chris Stookey on
-
-
Reply by 3fejfckwknd49 on
-
-
Reply by Chris Stookey on
-
-
Reply by 3fejfckwknd49 on
-
-
Reply by Chris Stookey on
Today we'll be reviewing the Tops Anaconda 7B, fixed blade knife. This combat survival knife was designed by custom knife maker, Ron Hood. His extensive outdoor experience is readily evident in his knife designs and his collaborations with Tops have yielded some very affordable, semi-custom knives. While the entire Tops product offering is extremely diverse, the Anaconda design stands out amongst some great competition. Lets see what makes this knife so unique.
Specifications
O/A Length: 13 1/4"
Blade Length: 7 1/2"
Thickness: 1/4"
Steel: 1095 High Carb.
Handle: Black Linen Micarta
Color: Black Traction Coating
Sheath: Combat Ballistic Nylon
Blade:
While the overall knife is very unique, from tip to tail, the Anaconda's blade is one of it's most important distinctions. As a full-tang design, the 1095 high-carbon steel runs the entire length of the knife, adding incredible power and durability to this big blade. Additionally, if you take good look at the shape of the entire knife, you'll see that it takes on a downward curve...somewhat reminiscent of the Kuhkri profile. Examination of the knife's cutting edge yields a very gradual recurve. While this aspect imparts the cutting power expected with recurves, it also enhances the chopping power inherent to the modified Kuhkri form. The combination of recurve and modified-Kuhkri create an angular relationship to the knife's handle, greatly enhancing energy for downward strokes.
The 7B version provides a modified drop point tip, excellent for slicing and piercing. Take note of the very usable double choil design. This allows the user to really "choke-up" when performing smaller cutting tasks that require "more precision". The blade grind begins at the halfway mark and while some may argue that this inhibits slicing performance (which it does), it adds tensile strength to the blade, improving durability. This feature, combined with the blade's shape, make the Anaconda an exceptional chopper/splitter. If you examine the spine of the blade, you'll notice 3 hooked notches. In addition to looking "mean", these little things come in handy (wire breaker, cookpot grabber). Like most Tops knives, the Anaconda comes scary sharp right out of it's package...and thanks to the differential heat treatment that the manufacturer gives it's 1095 steel, this knife holds it's edge remarkably well. Oddly, Tops knives seem to take well to resharpening; perhaps that too, is a by-product of the heat treatment?
Last, but not least, the blade is treated with a Black Traction Coating. Tops does a great job of finishing it's knives and this treatment serves to protect the blade. However, it does add "traction" to the blade (adding some resistance when cutting). So...splitting wood works "better" with a few squirts of WD-40. Though most people think of this lubricant as an industrial application product, trust me; it's a "must have" when you are in the great outdoors. A little can of WD-40 weighs very little and is worth every ounce. If you haven't tried this before, you should. In short order, you'll be making this a "fixture" within your load-out.
Handle: The Anaconda's handle shape plays an important role in the knife's overall ergonomic sensibility. As mentioned above, the handle has an angular relationship to the exposed blade. The main reason for this is to enhance chopping performance. That said, it's size, thickness and significant finger choil create real "lock in" when gripped. Additionally, there is a small thumb ramp at the point where the scales meet the exposed blade. While this knife is a "biggie", the handle and the thumb ramp allow the user to do remarkably precise cutting...the kind typically reserved for smaller, folding knives. The 7B model sports a 7 1/2" blade...which, while "big", isn't huge...and the handle's ergonomics make smaller cutting tasks "doable".
The scales are Black Linen Micarta. Nobody does this better than Tops. These scales provide excellent gription when dry...and crazy traction when wet. They are comfortable and keep the knife from transferring either heat or cold to a bare hand. That said, I recommend gloves when using large, fixed-blade knives. To be sure, the handle of the Anaconda works "perfectly" with gloves. In terms of coloration and aesthetics, the Black Linen Micarta just looks "very cool".
As it comes "out of the package", the Anaconda's handle is big enough for even the largest of hands. The design sports one serious "skull breaker" pommel. This exposed bit of steel features a lanyard hole...and the knife comes "tied up" from the factory. Tops uses a nice quality of cord on it's lanyard; something that some of it's competitors go "cheap" on.
Sheath: Fabricated from Combat Ballistic Nylon, the Anaconda's sheath is reasonably well made. The stitching is well done with no exposed fraying or stringing. The design is both belt and molle compatible. However, the belt connection leaves something to be desired; the sheath can slide around on anything but a larger military belt. The sheath includes the popular kangaroo pouch. This pocket is just big enough to hold a decent sized multi-tool, folding knife, sharpening system, fire-starter...or a variety of other pieces from a good survival kit. This pouch has a convenient and well-made snap that is easy to operate one-handed. The inner sleeve of the sheath is plastic and fits the blade just snugly enough to keep it from rattling around. The knife's handle is fastened with a Velcro snap system. This is a mistake. Tops: Please pay attention...and skip the obsession with Velcro. Go with a military-grade snap. It makes less noise and is more durable. While I'm not a huge fan of ballistic nylon, one of the things that I do like about this sheath is that the material muffles the knife and makes it a very "quiet companion".
In The Field: As indicated above, the Anaconda's design makes it a great chopper. In fact, it performs that task better than any other knife that I've used other than a Kuhkri. The heat treatment that Tops gives it's blades, makes the Anaconda an incredibly effective chopping tool. Generally speaking, it took only 2/3 the time to chop through a 3 1/4" piece of Vine Maple than it did with an OKC RD-9 (sporting 5160 spring steel). The Anaconda likes to chop! Additionally, it splits wood very well (as long as the user applies WD-40 in liberal amounts). The 7b's design, again as indicated above, allows the user to handle "smaller" cutting tasks surprisingly well. It almost supersedes the need for a folding knife (note that I said "almost"!). While this is a "bigger" knife, it isn't hulking. Also, the blade-to-handle relationship is extremely well balanced...making the Anaconda surprisingly fast in-hand.
To be sure, the Anaconda is one of the better designed survival knives that I've used. Additionally, the 7B version would make for an absolutely deadly defensive weapon. Most people visualize a knife's role in such an encounter as being one of slashing and stabbing. While the Anaconda can do these things well, it's additional chopping power makes it far more deadly. I have no doubt that, in the hands of a skilled user, the Anaconda could remove limbs in a single stroke. If I were headed in-country and knew that the possibility existed for deadly close-encounters, the Anaconda would likely be my first choice...even in spite of it's heft (it is heavy, though not outrageously so).
Second Kind of Cool: While the Anaconda comes in a few variations, the 7B version is my favorite. As fixed blade knives go, the unique shape, great materials, incredible balance and intimidating appearance score high on the Second Kind of Cool scale. It is "tactical" looking, but not crazily so...and there is an organic element to it that just "feels" right. To me, on a 1-10 scale (with 10 being the highest score possible), the 7B Anaconda scores a 9. Yep. Very "bad ass" cool.
Overall Take: This is probably my favorite fixed blade Tops knife. It is likely in my "All-time Top 5" list. What an outrageously incredible knife. From the woods to the desert to the jungle, the Anaconda 7B will perform well and keep coming back for more. Amazing as both a tool and a weapon, this knife is almost "perfect".
-
-
Reply by 3fejfckwknd49 on
-
-
Reply by Chris Stookey on
Today we'll be reviewing the Tops Loner model, medium-sized fixed blade knife. Though Tops is famous for having a large stable of unusual designs, the Jerry Van Cook designed Loner is quite unique. Lets find out what makes this sharp companion tick...
Specifications
O/A Length: 9 1/4"
Blade Length: 4 5/8"
Thickness: 3/16"
Steel: 1095 High Carbon Alloy
Handle: Black Linen Micarta
Color: Black Traction Coating
Sheath: Kydex
Blade: Made from 1095 High Carbon Alloy, the Loner's blade is largely what makes it such a unique knife. The shape brings together a variety of concepts and ends up being some kind of cross between a clip-point and a reverse-tanto. As a well established martial artist, Jerry Van Cook knows how knives can be used as weapons...and while the Loner is great for a host of utility tasks, there is no doubt that it's shape makes for a wicked self-defense tool. The large belly of the blade works exceptionally well for cutting and slicing, while the reverse-tanto tip is ideally suited to piercing. The blade is 3/16" thick...which is particularly burly for a medium-sized knife. The upper swedge of the blade is exposed steel...and sharpened; this knife "cuts both ways" and the user needs to keep this in mind 100% of the time. This added sharp edge increases the knife's overall effectiveness as a defense tool. Since the steel used is 1095, the exposed area is prone to rust...even when oiled. While the exposed area enhances the overall aesthetic of the knife, it creates a serious maintenance requirement that the user needs to stay on top of. The rest of the blade is coated in Tops superb black traction coating. As an owner of many Tops knives, I can tell you that this finish is super tough and really protects the knife quite well. The spine of the blade does offer some jimping, but with the upper swedge being sharpened, the user really shouldn't use this...and, fortunately, the handle design makes the jimping superfluous.
Handle: We've talked about the unique shape of the blade; in it's own way, the handle design is nearly as unique. Whereas the blade features the exaggerated clip-point belly, the handle arches it's back...giving the entire knife a bit of an "S" shape (somewhat similar to some Persian knives). The ergonomics of this shape work quite well and the knife feels exceptionally balanced in the hand. The linen micarta handle scales provide nearly flawless traction and, in typical fashion, Tops does a better job with this than any other maker that I've seen. The machining of the micarta is flawless. Attractive white spacers are located between the micarta handle scales and the tang of the blade. At the spine of the handle, just in front of the beginning of the blade, is a nicely curved thumb ramp. This feature works flawlessly, serving to lock the knife in the user's hand...which makes the knife extremely controllable. The version of the Loner that I own features the standard micarta scales; Tops offers the Rocky Mountain Tread treatment as well...AND it is very likely that I'll pick one up in that configuration!
Sheath: Often "simple" is good. Such is the case with the sheath that comes with the Loner. Made from high-durability kydex, it fits the knife perfectly...offering the kind of security that I wish every fixed-blade knife received. While kydex can scratch the surface of a blade, one of the upsides is that it doesn't hold water. With blades made from 1095 steel, this attribute is a serious PLUS. A basic metal belt clip provides the mounting method. While the steel used in the clip isn't terribly thick, it is extremely strong. Once the sheath is on your belt, that is just where it will stay. For users that like to molle-attach their knives to LBE, this sheath won't work. Basically, the super-simple design of the sheath works extremely well, but lacks any sort of flexibility. For me, this is a trade that I can live with...EASILY. For others, maybe not.
In The Field: The Loner is a very useful tool. Not big...and not small (though I do consider it a small "medium"), it is capable of easily handling every single type of CUTTING task that could be asked of a knife. It slices, it dices, it pierces, stabs and minces wonderfully. However, as is the case with most mid-to-small knives, "chopping" isn't it's forte. Sure, the 3/16" blade thickness helps it work through small saplings, twigs and even brush...but if you've got to hew through anything over 3/4" thick, plan on being there for ages (and using up an insane amount of energy). When it comes to up-close-and-personal self defense, I think that the Loner is one of the more useful knives ever made. While I lack the skill level and training of Jerry Van Cook, I've got just enough hands-on experience to understand what works...and can say that what Mr. Van Cook designed will work very well.
Second Kind of Cool: Obviously, when it comes to this category, a great degree of subjectivity comes into play. That preface aside, I think that the Loner is extremely cool. It's uber cool to use and it's unique design is so hot that it's cool. Yes, it lacks any fancy artistic element...but as tools go, the Loner rocks. As we've come to expect from Tops, the fit and finish on this knife is totally high-and-tight (Marine-speak for top-notch). On a 1-to-10 scale (with 10 being the highest score possible), I'll rate it a solid 8.
Overall Take: In simple terms, the Loner ranks as one of my all-time favorite mid-sized fixed blade knives. In terms of usefulness, I'd say that it comes as close to "perfect" as anything I've owned and used. It's relatively compact size makes it a great companion. It's build quality makes it a lifetime knife (short of user extreme-abuse and neglect, the Loner will last indefinitely). The only real downside to this knife it it's exposed 1095 swedge. Mine has experienced a tiny spot of rust...in spite of my anal-retentive maintenance schedule. Fortunately, I like handling it so much that working that rust off was a labor of love. As if the maintenance burden of one Loner wasn't enough, I'm planning on getting another one...with Tops' awesome Rocky Mountain Tread treatment on the micarta handle scales. Guess I'll have to stock up on oil...
-
-
Reply by Chris Stookey on
Today we'll be reviewing what is quite possibly one of the most controversial fixed blade knife designs ever produced, the Tom Brown Tracker as manufactured by Tops Knives. For those unfamiliar with this blade or the designer, here's a little history:
Tom Brown: Tom Brown Jr. is one of America's most notable wilderness survival experts. Mr. Brown has run a survival school since 1978 and has over 30 years of experience in the field. His accomplishments in this arena are many and of particular significance. In a niche populated by a variety of competent experts, his approach is truly unique in that it has grown from the roots of the most successful of wilderness survivors; the American Indian.
Tom Brown Jr.'s interest in the American Wilderness was fostered through the mentoring of a Lipan Apache by the name of Stalking Wolf. This Native American's story deserves more acknowledgment than I can provide in this article. Suffice it to say that Tom Brown Jr. was the fortunate recipient of Stalking Wolf's knowledge (gathered over 83 years of life experience outside reservations and as passed down to him through his Apache ancestry).
There are many ways to find out more about Mr. Brown. Here are two quick recommendations:
* Via the web at: www.trackerschool.com. This is the web site for Tom Brown's survival school. There is a veritable ton of great information on the site and while I haven't applied to become a student of the school (only due to current life obligations), if you have any real interest in wilderness survival, I strongly encourage you to explore the sampling that the site offers.
* Via his acclaimed book: Tom Brown's Field Guide to Wilderness Survival. If you want a succinct compendium on wilderness survival, this easy-reading book is an asset no survivalist should be without. Published in 1983, Mr. Brown's Field Guide consists of 276 pages of invaluable information on topics such as; shelter, tools, animals, plants, traps, fire-making and more. What makes this book particularly noteworthy is that it eschews reliance upon commercially available camping gear. Living off the land? Yes...LITERALLY.
The Tracker Knife Design: The term "controversial" has certainly been attached to Mr. Brown's Tracker Knife design. Predominately, the "controversy" centers around the shape of the blade and it's usefulness; we'll address this as we review the current iterations offered by Tops Knives. Tops currently produces two versions of the Tracker; the Tracker and the Tracker II. In simple terms, these are basically the same knife with one major difference; size. Given that neither of the knives are "small", it's perhaps easier to consider the Tracker as the "large" model and the Tracker II as the "medium" version. Lets get rolling...
"Large" Tracker Specifications
O/A Length: 11 7/8"
Blade Length: 4 1/4"
Thickness: 1/4"
Steel: 1095 High Carbon Alloy RC58
Handle: Black Linen Micarta
Color: Black Traction Coating
Sheath: Kydex"Medium" Tracker Specifications
O/A Length: 9 1/2"
Blade Length: 3 1/2"
Thickness: 3/16"
Steel: 1095 High Carbon Alloy RC58
Handle: Black Linen Micarta
Color: Black Traction Coating
Sheath: Kydex
Blade: Made from 1095 High Carbon Alloy, the shape and grind of the Tracker knives is a huge part of what makes them so different from most survival knives. Describing the shape is a challenge...so for the sake of clarity, we'll break the design down into 4 quadrants; the Lower Front Edge, the Lower Rear Edge, the Upper Front Spine and the Upper Rear Spine.
* Lower Front Edge: This area represents roughly half of the blade's lower cutting edge. The front half consists of a modified clip-shape...one with a tremendous amount of belly to it. As is the case with most knives, this portion of the knife handles the lion's share of the most common knife chores (slicing, piercing, chopping).
* Lower Rear Edge: This area is often referred to as the "draw knife" portion. Generally, this part of the blade is designed for specialized tasks. However, the available overall cutting area isn't large enough to eliminate the possibility of this portion getting used for chopping functions.
* Upper Front Spine: Comprises the very tip of the blade...and provides a set of serrated teeth. The serrations serve to perform a variety of functions, not the least of which is "sawing".
* Upper Rear Spine: Makes up the last half of the blade's spine prior to meeting the handle. It is humped and provides the user with a couple of control mechanisms...including a jimped thumb ramp.
As you can gather from the 4 quadrants described above, the Tracker's blade shape provides the user with a carefully thought out set of tools. As is the case with any set of tools, the correct deployment of said tools requires that the user know how to use them. Since these tools go beyond what most people encounter with nearly every other knife design currently available in the market, the Tracker is often mis-labeled as being nothing more than a good theatrical prop (the knife's largest exposure came from a film called "The Hunted"). In an oddly ironic twist of fate, while Hollywood has created some public awareness of the Tracker design, it has also served to "turn off" several knife enthusiasts. Too bad for those folks...and good news to those of you willing to overlook Hollywood's taint.
While 1095 has long been known as one of the best steels for survival blades, the heat treat that Tops uses makes it even better. Over the steel, Tops applies what they call their "Black Traction Coating". This treatment consists of a fine grade of baked-on hybrid epoxy and poly powder coating. It is super durable and protects the knife against rust and corrosion. Tops successfully tested this finish against 1300 hours of exposure to salt water spray. Salt water is one of the most corrosive materials that steel can be exposed to. Additionally, Tops tested the steel and it's finish for resistance to solvents and impact; the tests were very successful.
Both the larger and medium-sized Trackers came from the factory with incredibly sharp and beautifully finished blades. The knives are full tang constructed and with thicknesses of 1/4" and 3/16" respectively. These steel thicknesses were chosen for the ability to endure just about any scenario likely to be encountered in the wilderness. The knives feature aesthetically impressive logo work, adding a little "extra" exclusivity.
Handle: The handle shape on both Trackers is a study in the natural form of the human hand. Certainly every knife maker purports to have designed a knife with "the best ergonomics yet". Often, in striving for a point of differentiation in the market, they over-complicate the handle shapes of their knives. Tom Brown's design is remarkably simple. The front two finger choils are ideally located and accommodate a variety of hand sizes well. The rear of the handle curves to follow the natural shape of the hand's palm. Along the spine of the handle, the edges are nicely rounded...with just enough jimping to provide the user's thumb a perfect spot for control. All in all, the shape recognizes the tasks that will be asked of the knife.The Tops versions of the Tracker feature dark red spacers between the blade's tang and the Black Linen Micarta scales. The workmanship on both the spacers and the scales is simply impeccable. Each edge of the handle is smoothed and curved and remarkably comfortable. For those users that appreciate the utility of a lanyard, the butt of both knives feature a brass lanyard hole. The quality of the work on ever facet of the handle is a testament as to why Tops Knives command a higher price than their less expensive counterparts. Truly, this user has never seen better Linen Micarta scales than those done by Tops. Just as the exposed blade area features impressive logo work, so does the handle scale; the Tops logo is highlighted in black. This isn't easy to do on Micarta as it's porous nature tends to blur inks. That Tops does such a good job with this is yet another statement of quality.
Sheath: Both the larger and the medium Tracker come with extremely well done kydex sheaths. The knives fit their sheaths tightly enough that they don't make unwanted noise during storage or deployment; both actions provide a definite-yet polite audible confirmation. One of the benefits of kydex is that it doesn't hold moisture. Given that these knives have 1095 steel, this is a smart move by Tops. The knives feature extremely strong metal belt clips. When these sheaths are attached to the user's belt, they STAY attached. To be sure, the sheathes are designed more for belt carry than attachment to a pack of LBE.
In The Field: As indicated above, the Tracker shape is controversial. Indeed, a variety of notable reviewers have looked upon it unfavorably. As also mentioned above, the design provides a set of tools that the user needs to understand and have the skill to properly utilize. From this owner's perspective, the shape of the Tracker is extremely useful. That said, it's usefulness is best realized with the larger model.The Lower Front Edge of the knife performs nearly all of the cutting tasks users encounter quite well; the sole exception being scenarios that require a long slicing cut. A simple point of fact, even on the larger Tracker, the bellied cutting edge isn't long enough to handle a large slice without multiple passes. However, whether you are cutting fabric, cordage, or skinning an animal, the Tracker performs very well. In terms of piercing power, the Tracker is nearly impossible to beat with anything except a spear point. The thickness of the knife's tip makes this one incredibly powerful tool.
Additionally, the Lower Front Edge quadrant of the blade works exceptionally well for chopping. Undoubtedly, experienced fixed blade owners have baton'd a blade through wood. Done it? Then you know just how much work it really is. The fact of the matter is that an axe is a vastly superior chopping tool. So...the Tracker isn't an axe, but the shape is a hybridization of axe and knife. It's chopping ability reflects this. However, even the larger Tracker's blade length isn't large enough to go through anything but smaller pieces of wood. The good news though is that really, nobody with an ounce of survival experience is going to go splitting logs with a knife. Why? There is no need to...when smaller saplings will provide all that you need...and, in a wilderness environment, it isn't smart to burn the amount of energy required to split logs. The combination of handle and blade shapes make the Tracker a good "compromise" chopper when an axe just isn't available.
The Lower Rear Edge, as indicated above, provides a draw knife area. This is particularly handy when it comes to shelter making. Stripping the bark off a log is handled effectively with this portion of the blade (by the way, survivalists know that bark can be a very useful material). It also works well when splitting cordage, peeling vines and other small tasks that require precise control. A word of advice; wear gloves when doing this kind of work. Aside from the obvious, remember that the Upper Front Spine has saw teeth. And they are quite sharp. The jimping on the Upper Rear Spine of the blade is quite helpful when using the draw knife tool.
The Upper Front Spine's saw teeth are remarkably handy. In spite of their bulky size, they are sharp enough to cut quite well (though sharpening them isn't the easiest of tasks). Sawing through saplings is accomplished effectively...though again, WEAR GLOVES (and keep in mind that the blade's cutting edge faces up when you use the saw teeth). Also, the gap between teeth makes for a nifty wire handle lifter (steel cooking pots come with wire handles; get the picture?). It also functions well as a wire "breaker" in the event that you encounter an odd bit of wire in the wilderness and need to remove it .
While this user has seen better "choppers"...and better "slicers" when it comes to survival knives, I've never encountered a knife that offered more practical flexibility than the Tracker design. That "flexibility" is critical in a survival context because you will have to make your own tools out of natural materials. No knife design that I've seen addresses this reality better. Yes, the larger Tracker is kind of heavy...but if you take into account the tool-set that you are getting, it becomes quite compact and weight efficient.
While most of what I've said above is applicable to the larger Tracker, the medium-sized Tracker does an admirable job given it's scaled-down mass. Aside from chopping, it is an extraordinarily effective blade.
Second Kind of Cool: Tops did a fantastic job manufacturing the Tracker. Both sizes feature absolutely superb quality. In terms of aesthetics, the extremely unique and aggressive shape of the Tracker is perhaps best described as "impressively intimidating". It displays an odd contrast between gently flowing lines and hard, primitively sharp edges. If you prefer the term "bad ass", then yes, the Trackers are very "bad ass". In terms of practical flexibility, Mr. Brown's design is absolutely like that of no other knife; it's well-thought out tool set is naturally magnificient. That...simply put...is very COOL.
Overall Take: Perfectly executed, Tops-produced Tom Brown Trackers are superb cutting tools. The design is remarkably unique; for today's modernized minds, it's nature-influenced concept often eludes comprehension. Once you understand the design's tool system and abilities, you discover just how useful a survival knife the Tracker is. Candidly, if I had to choose just one knife to take with me into a wilderness survival situation, it actually would be the larger Tracker. I simply disagree with the design's nay-sayers...who may have been wrongly influenced by this excellent blade's abuse at the hands of Hollywood producers.
-
-
Reply by Chris Stookey on
Today we'll be reviewing the Tops Steel Eagle 107E. The Steel Eagle platform is available in a few different configurations including different blade shapes, lengths, and serrations. The 107E configuration is but one of the variations available.
Specifications
O/A Length: 13"
Blade Length: 7"
Thickness: 1/4"
Steel: 1095 High Carb.
Handle: Black Linen Micarta
Color: Black Traction Coating
Sheath: Nylon
Blade: Like many of Tops Knives blades, the Steel Eagle features a 1/4" thick and 7" long cutting edge. The knife has a full-tang design and the 1/4" thick steel runs the entire length of the knife. While some users will say that this construction is a bit "overdone", remember that the Steel Eagle series is designed for extreme outdoor use/survival application. With a 60/40 grind to it, the knife is specifically oriented to heavy-duty work. The Steel Eagle's drop point shape provides the ideal in flexibility and will handle a wide variety of tasks. Additionally, a well-positioned choil allows the user to "choke up" on the blade when performing cutting tasks that require a bit more precision. A nicely executed thumb ramp tops off the blade area's overall shape. The ramp is effectively jimped and works extremely well.1095 High Carbon steel has a strong propensity towards rusting. Fortunately, Tops protects the steel in this knife with it's Black Traction Coating. To my experience, this protectant still needs to be lubricated with oil...but with a little bit of regular maintenance, works quite well. Some users have commented that the Black Traction Coating adds resistance when cutting. Personally, I have experienced this...but to a very small extent and consider the trade-off of having enhanced steel protection "worth it".
Relative to the selection of 1095 steel for this knife, I think it a perfect choice. While there are certainly harder steels...and even stainless steels available, 1095 is better suited to outdoor/survival applications. Why?
* It isn't brittle and has a little "give" to it. In the "great outdoors", your blade is certain to come into contact with the ground, rocks, exceptionally hard knots in wood...bones (if you hunt) and other "tough" objects. Rather than chipping or cracking (like some other steels would do), 1095 is more likely to "dent"...and dents can be sharpened out.
* It is easy to sharpen, but holds an edge relatively well. In the field, you don't always have a couple of hours (and a host of sharpening tools) to devote to sharpening. I've found that even very dull edges on 1095 can be restored in a half hour or less.
Handle: The Steel Eagle sports Tops Knives' Black Linen Micarta handle scales. These grips are attached to the knife's tang with screws; so the scales can be removed should the user need to replace them. A nice aesthetic touch is added with the white spacers located immediately beneath the Black Linen Micarta. As I've indicated in previous Tops Knives reviews, no manufacturer does a better job with Linen Micarta than Tops. The handle scales on the Steel Eagle are yet another perfect example. The machining is cleanly executed and swells and curves are located in "all the right places", providing the user with a remarkably comfortable grip. As the scales do not fully encase the tang of the knife, the exposed steel can react to the surrounding weather (hot or cold). Of course, if the user is wearing gloves, this becomes a "non-issue".The shape of the handle is well designed, providing a larger index finger choil to increase grip. Behind this choil, the remaining area is large enough to comfortably accomodate large palms without crowding the respective three fingers. The spine of the handle provides jimping in a couple of locations for even more positive purchase. One of the particularly intelligent aspects of the Steel Eagle revolves around the exposed pommel area. The tang exposes some very useful steel beyond the ending of the scales. In addition to providing a handy "hammer" type of tool, this portion of the handle has a pair of lanyard holes; one is located at the top while the other is located at the bottom. Past offering twice the lanyard locations of the competition's knives, it also presents some interesting spear-oriented possibilities.
Sheath: Like many other Tops Knives, the Steel Eagle comes with a ballistic nylon sheath. The sheath is pretty standard fair for Tops. Over the years, I've hard some reviewers say that they dislike ballistic nylon sheaths and prefer kydex. Primarily, they support their argument with the fact that kydex weighs less and doesn't hold water. Seems like solid thinking, doesn't it? I generally agree. Note that I said "generally" and not "completely". Well, really, a well done ballastic nylon sheath offers up some advantages that it's kydex counterparts do not. The sheath design that Tops used on the Steel Eagle provides a fairly decent example:
* It comes with a plastic insert. This insert doesn't hold water and has a drainage hole (though it isn't easy to see at a glance).
* Ballastic nylon is QUIET. It doesn't rattle or "clack" like kydex or exposed plastic. If I have to tell you why "quiet" is good, you are either a neophyte to the subject matter or just plain ignorant. In the wilderness, noise isn't usually a good thing and you need to be able to be "quiet". In a military scenario, "quiet" is an absolute necessity. Oh...and for those "modern thinkers" espousing opinions to the effect that knives have no place in today's military; spend some time in the field. Live it; don't armchair quarterback. In fact, lets change the theater of operations from desert to jungle or forest. In that environment, knives aren't an accessory, they become one of your MOST important tools.
* Ballastic nylon sheaths generally feature A LOT of attachment options...both for direct load...and for LBE. The Tops sheaths take this into account and include plenty of molle attachment straps...as well as some 550 para cord tie-down.
* Tops ballastic nylon sheaths feature a little additional storage pocket. Some users "poo-poo" this advantage, but if you are in the field, that pocket comes in handy. Here are a couple of quick uses for it; sharpening stone...multi-tool...small flashlight...fire-starter...snake-bite kit. Try it for a while and you'll discover many more uses for it. It doesn't add any real additional weight, but certainly gives you an additional (and ideally located) storage option. Options are good, right? Right!
Though I've extolled some "virtues" to the ballastic nylon sheath that Tops provides, I have to pitch a complaint. I really wish that the fine folks at Tops would loose their obsession with velcro. I prefer quality snaps to velcro every day of the week. They don't make noise (remember, "quiet" is good). Also, for the Steel Eagle, Tops decided to go with TWO velcro straps for the handle. If you need two straps to keep the knife in the sheath, the design is...I'll be blunt here...SCREWED UP. Two straps equal twice the handle and 10 times the noise. Good grief, Tops! Opening a single strap makes enough noise to wake the dead...and opening two straps creates a cacophony! Dump the velcro! PLEASE!!! By the way, I actually shouted that request. Ok...sometimes quiet isn't a good thing...
In The Field: I've used a lot of knives over the years and the Steel Eagle is certainly one of my favorites. This knife is darn near "ideal" in that it is large enough to handle heavy use, but small enough to perform cutting tasks very well.It's size and relative "stoutness" make it capable of handling extreme tasks. Batoning wood illustrates this quite well. Though it isn't the largest of the Steel Eagle series, the 7" blade is big enough to accomodate the splitting of good sizes rounds of wood. Additionally, the 60/40 blade grind is ideally suited to this task; the shape of the blade performs like a wedge...forcing the wood fibers to split as the knife is batonned through material. Of course, the fact that the steel is 1/4" thick at the spine...helps.
One of the most enjoyable aspects of the 107E is the fact that it feels smaller than it's 13" overall length. It maintains a surprising agility that is extremely welcome. Even under sustained use, this model works to mitigate fatigue. THAT IS THE SIGN OF A GREAT KNIFE DESIGN. Obviously, this particular element allows the knife to perform quite well when applied to "smaller" cutting tasks. Candidly, I've found that works remarkably well at everything but the smallest of tasks. It even works to remove splinters without hogging out an excessive amount of flesh. Pretty handy!
For you military types, the 107E offers some effective ability as a weapon. Again, the aforementioned agility is what makes the Steel Eagle viable in this particular arena. The blade length isn't so extensive as to make the blade too cumbersome to wield in a defensive encounter. Also, that drop point shape will do it's part in such a role.
Second Kind of Cool: While I love the shape of the 107E, it's real "coolness" is only discovered under use. Certainly, the quality that Tops put into this knife is inarguably impressive. However, the knife has an extremely "understated" appearance. In the case of the Steel Eagle, it's all about performance for this all-business blade.Overall Take: In simple terms, the Steel Eagle 107E is one of Tops Knives best blades. It is a real performer and is a real joy to use. While it's price tag isn't "super affordable", what you get for the money makes every penny worth it.
-
-
Reply by Chris Stookey on
Today we'll be reviewing the Tops Armageddon. Tops offers an extremely wide range of fixed blade knives, ranging from very small to extremely large. Designer Trace Rinaldi's Armageddon certainly falls into the latter category and the review's direction takes this into consideration.
Specifications- O/A Length: 16 1/2"
- Blade Length: 10 5/8"
- Thickness: 1/4"
- Steel: 1095 High Carb. RC 58
- Handle: Green/Black G-10
- Color: Black Traction Coating
- Weight: 24 oz.
- Sheath: Nylon
Blade: The Armageddon's blade is made from 1/4" thick 1095 High Carbon Steel. The steel features Tops differential heat treat and has an ideal hardness of RC58. I use the word "ideal" because outdoor "extreme use" knives need to be tough, but not brittle. While 1095 is universally recognized as an excellent steel for this purpose, if not hardened enough, it will have an overt tendency to "dent". Given that big blades are frequently used for "chopping", it's important that the knife steel used have some give to it...but not too much. Tops does a great job of finding that "just right" hardness.The blade's shape displays a very gradual recurve. This subtle orientation provides the user with some of the cutting/slicing advantages that recurved blades generally offer without quite so much of the challenge when sharpening. Additionally, the blade is full-flat ground. Mr. Rinaldi intended for the Armageddon to be a cross between a machete and a chopping knife. The shape and grind of the knife suit this objective perfectly. The tip of the blade displays a nice amount of belly and yet retains a pronounced tip. Though the knife is a little large to make the best use of this feature, it can come in handy from time to time.
Handy spine jimping is correctly located between the juncture of the blade and the handle. With the blade's 10 5/8" length, this control-oriented ergonomic gets used more than one would anticipate. Unfortunately, the spine is completely flat and lacks a thumb ramp. So...while the jimping is a welcome addition, the lack of a ramp makes it a little less effective than it would otherwise be. That said, the knife is primarily intended for use as a chopper...and the jimping isn't a critical feature for that particular application.
Handle: Like most of Tops Knives' fixed blades, the Armageddon sports black linen micarta handle scales. They are superbly executed and fit the knife's full tang construction perfectly. The scales on this particular edition of the Armageddon are "plain"; there is a Rocky Mountain Tread version available as well (though that wasn't the case when I purchased the knife shown in the photo...otherwise I would have gotten that one instead). Strikingly good looking white spacers are located between the micarta scales and the tang. In simple terms, I've never encountered a knife manufacturer that does a better job with micarta than Tops and the Armageddon's handle is a perfect example of how effective a material this can be.Given the large size of this knife...and that it's use is mostly geared towards "chopping", handle shape plays a critical role in overall control-ability of the knife. Mr. Rinaldi did an exceptional job in designing the Armageddon's handle. The shape effectively accommodates quite a range of hand sizes, with choil and guard locations that allow users to choke-up on the blade or move back a little for added momentum on larger "chops". As my hands are kind of..."beefy", I really appreciate the real estate; it makes for a very comfortable grip and reduces fatigue over extended chopping sessions.
At the butt of the handle, the knife sports a hooked pommel that works well as a striking device (you can pound nails with it...though, at only 1/4" thick, you better have "good aim"). The "hook" also serves to keep the knife from pulling out the hand when you are removing it from wood (think "batoning"). The hook also has two holes in it and Tops placed a semi-useful lanyard here. I describe it as "semi-useful" because the paracord's ends are open. Obviously, the user can simply tie the ends together to complete the lanyard.
Sheath: The Armageddon's sheath, like most of those supplied with Tops fixed blade knives, is made from ballistic nylon. The quality of the material is good and includes some useful 550 paracord to assist in fastening (the overall sheath design is geared towards the Molle system). The sheath has a plastic insert...that LACKS A DRAIN HOLE (the nylon follows suit). Why on earth the sheath for a HUGE fixed blade knife wouldn't have a drain hole is beyond me...but Tops certainly flunked the "intelligence test" in this regard. Nobody wants a sheath holding 10 5/8" of high carbon steel to retain water. Unfortunately, this isn't the sheath's only shortcoming; the handle of the knife is held in place with a Velcro snap. What is it with Tops and their obsession with Velcro?! I need to write Mike Fuller a letter on this topic; SKIP THE VELCRO AND GO WITH A MILITARY GRADE SNAP...LIKE THE ONE ON THE BACK OF THE SHEATH USED FOR MOLLE ATTACHMENT. Velco is obnoxiously noisy (which is NOT a good thing) and doesn't hold up against moisture and cold.Last, but not least, the sheath features a little kangaroo pouch on the front with a nice buckle snap. As I've indicated in previous Tops Knives reviews, I like these little pouches. I realize that many other reviewers castigate the pouches as "worthless"; I disagree. You can store some absolutely necessary items in that pouch...ones that need to be accessed easily (multi-tool, fire-starter, folding knife...just to mention a few things).
In The Field: As indicated above, Mr. Rinaldi designed this knife to function as a small machete. At 16 1/2" in overall length, the Armageddon does this extremely well. Much larger and we couldn't really continue to call this a knife! The full-flat grind makes it an excellent batoning tool (think chopping wood for fire fuel). The subtle recurve on the blade shape also makes the knife surprisingly effective for slicing. As the name implies, the Armageddon is one big knife. It is extremely well made and stands up VERY well to hard use.Really, the Armageddon is not well-suited to smaller cutting tasks. It isn't so huge that you can't make a go of the little chores...but I've found that it will make you work twice as hard to finish these as you will with a smaller knife. What does this mean...in practical terms? Bring a folding knife with you. A smart outdoors-person does this anyway...but it never hurts to offer the readers a little useful reminder.
At 24 ounces, the knife weighs quite a bit and it's Molle sheath orientation makes it tempting to strap onto my pack. However, I've found that strapping it to my left thigh for cross-draw works extremely well...and the weight works to balance out the large revolver carried on my right hip.
Second Kind of Cool: In a quiet way that belies it's macho name, the Armageddon sports a very calm and subdued "coolness". You know the kind. It doesn't have to brag about it's abilities because it will outwalk any of the proverbial talk. An experienced knife user will "get" this the second that they pick the knife up. In terms of aesthetics, this isn't a knife that shouts "Look at me!" from the mountain tops. This isn't a collector's blade; the Armageddon is absolutely meant for use in the Great Outdoors.
Overall Take: While there certainly are a variety of knife designs (by Tops as well as other manufacturers) that I like better, the Armageddon is an undeniably effective field tool. If the knife had a thumb-ramp, it'd be just a bit "better"...and that is about all the criticism that I can level against it. However...and yes, here's the "yeah but" part of the review; the sheath is a C-grade. For a knife this expensive (yep, it ain't particularly "affordable"), it should come with an A-grade sheath. No...I'm not saying that the material has to be better than ballistic nylon. The insert should be kydex, not plastic. It should have a drain hole (as should the nylon). The strap should be a military-grade snap, not that infernal Velcro. The sheath irritates me enough that I may have one custom made...because I like the knife well enough to do that.
-
-
Reply by Chris Stookey on
In today's "tactical" trend, fixed blade knives tend to gravitate towards "large" and "huge". Sometimes, however, you need a knife that is compact and light...but that maintains the strength and durability that can only be had with a fixed blade. Tops Knives offers a veritable host of blades that fit that bill. Today we'll be taking a look at one such example; the Jim Burke-designed Mini Extractor.
Specifications
O/A Length: 8 1/2"
Blade Length: 4"
Thickness: 5/32"
Steel: 1095 High Carb.
Handle: Blue/Black G-10
Color: Black Traction Coating
Sheath: Kydex
Blade: At 4" long, the Mini Extractor's blade shape is best defined as a modified drop point. The upper spine sports a well-jimped thumb ramp. This particular feature provides the user with exceptional control during cutting tasks that require a higher degree of precision. Heading towards the tip of the blade, the upper spine displays a crisply-ground false swedge; this gives the knife some extra aesthetic "pop". Certainly, the swedge would be easy enough to sharpen if the user desired to do so. In terms of grind profile, the Mini Extractor feels like a 3/4 flat grind...though to the eye it almost looks somewhat convex. The cutting edge is razor sharp and nicely polished.Made of Tops' 1095 High Carbon steel, the Mini Extractor's blade is durable, somewhat forgiving and easy to sharpen. As we all know, 1095 steel has a significant propensity to rust. Fortunately, Tops finishes the knife with it's very effective "Black Traction Coating". Personally, I've had nothing but good experiences with this finish...though I've certainly seen online comments indicating that a number of people think that the "traction" texture of the coating inhibits the slicing ability of a knife. As a popular YouTube reviewer likes to say, "Your mileage may vary."
As users and collectors, if we're honest with ourselves, we'll admit that a blade's aesthetic "wow" plays a role in the decision of whether or not we buy a knife. The advertising that Tops puts on the Mini Extractor is perfectly displayed with one side of the blade proudly proclaiming the Tops' logo..and the reverse side giving designer Jim Burke some well-earned recognition. This "signage" gives the blade some added appeal.
Handle: For those familiar with his work, Jim Burke has a rather unusual approach to knife design. His folders tend to be "big and broad". As an interesting exercise in contrast, he took a radically different angle when working-out the shape of the Mini Extractor's handle.This knife...as is the case with most Tops blades...has a full-tang, providing well-proven strength and the kind of constitution that folders just don't have. A quick look at the photo shows that this is one slim handle. Indeed, both the profile (1") and the thickness (roughly 11/16" overall) of the handle are SUPER slim. Running only 4 1/2" in length...and being as slender as it is, you'd think that this design would cause the knife to be "blade heavy". If anything, the "balance point" of the knife is located about an inch to the rear of the front choil.
The Mini Extractor's handle scales are a particularly handsome looking blue and black G10. The texture on the G10 is very subdued...but not polished. Interestingly, a little bit of moisture seems to..."encourage" the G10 to give the user just a touch more gription. Underneath the G10 are strikingly beautiful red spacers. This combination is quite subtle until you view the spine of the handle...at which point your eyeballs get a healthy dose of eye candy.
The handle is shockingly comfortable in hand. In spite of how slim it is, the knife doesn't feel like it is going to slip out of the hand. With a decently-sized front choil, a reasonably curved area near the butt of the handle...and a gentle swell in the center...the knife rides in the user's palm...quite comfortably and seems to fight fatigue nicely.
Sheath: Candidly, it doesn't get much simpler than this; friction-fit kydex with a tough metal belt clip. Kydex holds up better than just about anything else. That said, unless the fit from knife to sheath is pretty much "perfect", the blade will rattle when sheathed. So how's the Mini Extractor's sheath perform under the "noise test"? Well, if you take a second to seat it "totally", it's pretty quiet. However, if you rush it in...or are experiencing some very vigorous physical activity...the knife can loosen just a touch in the sheath. Yes, that means "noise"...though not a ton of it. As for the metal belt clip...well it's VERY tough, super easy to use...but greatly limits how you can mount it to your LBE (Load Bearing Equipment). So...on a 1-to-10 scale (with "10" being the best possible), I give the sheath a solid 7.
In The Field: The Mini Extractor is a surprising performer of a knife. At only 8 1/2" long, it's quite compact. The super slim handle helps make it a lot more "carryable" than many of it's contemporaries. The 4" blade is an ideal size for EDC tasks. It's full-tang design makes it more durable than any folder made. The modified drop point blade shape is probably the most versatile currently in existence. Think that this knife is too little for survival work? Think again. An experienced user can make superb use of this knife's capabilities. Short of trying to baton through logs, the Mini Extractor is a real work horse that doesn't fatigue the user's hand as much as some other designs. How about self-defense? Well, I'd take this over a folder any day of the week! Really...in nearly a year of ownership, there isn't much that I've encountered that can't be handled with this little companion.
Second Kind of Cool: The knife looks good. The blue and black G10 with red spacers...and the uber-tactical blade shape just draw the eyes. It feels good in the hand...enough that I found my hand being drawn to the knife...almost of it's own volition. Ok...it doesn't have eye-popping Damascus steel. It lacks the mind-bending beauty of wood burl. Still, there is just "something" about this knife that is cooler than I can effectively describe with words. Maybe that coolness comes from how well it performs? That's gotta be it. This knife is just too subtle-looking for this to be a really visual experience. Whatever it is, Jim Burke did an outstanding job with the Mini Extractor. Of course, I shouldn't leave out the FACT that the build quality of the knife is OUTSTANDING.
Overall Take: There are a bunch of smaller tactical fixed blades available on the market. VERY few of them can stand toe-to-toe with the Mini Extractor. There are very few knives I've used that work as well as this little blade does. As if that weren't enough, here's a little good news; it's affordable. Note that I said "affordable" and not "inexpensive". Ounce for ounce, this knife is worth more than you'll pay.
-
-
White River Knives
Latest Activity
Visit Lee' s Cutlery
KNIFE AUCTIONS
KNIFE MAGAZINE!!!
tsaknives.com
JSR Sports!
Click to visit
© 2024 Created by Jan Carter.
Powered by
Today we'll be reviewing the Tops Mountain Lion, fixed blade knife. This knife was designed with input from members of the US 10th Mountain Division. The 10th Mountain Division is categorized as "Light Infantry", which means that they may be deployed in a variety of military theaters. The troops of this division are specifically geared to fight in exceptionally harsh conditions. The gear that they have to bring with them absolutely has to stand up to the most rigorous of applications. The Tops Mountain Lion was built to serve this military group well.
Specifications
O/A Length: 10 3/4"
Blade Length: 5 1/2"
Thickness: 1/4"
Steel: 1095 High Carb.
Handle: Green/Black G-10
Color: Black Traction Coating
Sheath: Nylon
Blade: Made from 1095 high carbon steel, the Mountain Lion's blade is geared for hard outdoor use. At 1/4" thick, this brawny piece of US Metal has a modified drop point shape that is perfect for chopping, slicing, stabbing and even digging without skipping a beat. At 5 1/2" long, the Mountain Lion is well sized for the majority of tasks for which we would use a knife. The good folks at Tops made sure to give this large-medium blade a nice choil to choke-up on when the chore at hand requires cutting precision. The upper spine of the blade features wide jimping, the kind that works especially well with gloves; again added CONTROL! The majority of the blade is finished with a Black Traction Coating. The upper swedge is unfinished and the owner will need to take care to keep this area well oiled. 1095 may be a great outdoor steel, but it's high carbon content makes it rather vulnerable to rust.
Handle: The Mountain Lion is built with full-tang construction. Over the tang are some beautiful maroon-red spacers that add a very nice aesthetic element. Finally, the spacers are covered in black and green G10. The G10 is smoothly-machined and feels warm to the touch. The color combination of black and green give this burly knife a robust military "vibe". The ergonomic shape of the handle is, quite literally, "perfect". It feels fast, light and very natural in the hand...like an extension of the body. NOW THAT'S HOW A KNIFE SHOULD FEEL! Positives stated, there are a few design flaws that need to be mentioned. First, the G10 should have been more aggressively checkered. As is, the knife is "slicker" than it should be. Second, the handle should have come with a lanyard hole. I find this absence downright shocking. I understand the military application of this knife; a lanyard is a must-have.
Sheath:Made from ballistic nylon, the sheath is reasonably well constructed. The snap on the stone pouch works very well and is of decent quality. Other than that, the sheath design is terrible. Good knives should always come with good sheathes. Tops should know this inside out. Oddly, they often seem to miss the proverbial boat when it comes to sheathes. So...what's so bad about this sheath? Well, the plastic insert doesn't hold the blade tightly; the knife rattles around inside it. The handle of the knife is held in place with not one, but TWO Velcro straps. Two? Maybe the designer was intensely afraid that the knife's owner would loose his blade in the field? This seems an ironic concern given how loosely the knife fits the insert. In tactical applications, Velcro is a liability (it makes a horrendous amount of noise...and with this sheath, you'd have to make that racket twice to get to your blade!). Under long-term use, Velcro is a liability. It fuzzes up and wears poorly when wet. Given where the 10th Division typically goes, it's safe to say that this sheath (and the knife) will get wet. It would be fairly simple (and cost-effective) for Tops to improve this sheath; A) make the insert fit the knife and B) replace the Velcro straps with a single snap.
In The Field: The Mountain Lion is a very well-built knife. It is durable from butt to tip. The knife's full-tang construction makes it particularly good at chopping in spite of it's somewhat shorter length. The blade's 1/4" thickness makes it a good splitter for smaller diameter logs. The blade shape has a mild recurve to it that works very well for slicing. To some extent, the recurve offsets the knife's stocky girth. As a moderate size knife, the Mountain Lion handles bushcraft chores very well. The design of the knife facilitates both larger and smaller cutting tasks VERY well. As indicated above, the sheath is a detraction and while I didn't have any occasion to require stealth (I could have been avoiding the wildlife present in the wilderness in this region), the double Velcro straps were very irritating to deal with.
Second Kind of Cool: Aesthetically, the Mountain Lion is undeniably COOL. Some may even think it super cool. The color combination, shape, fit and finish, awesome spacers...all add up to make this one of the more attractive fixed blade knives on the market. AWESOME.
Overall Take: As cool as the Mountain Lion is...and as much as it does well, the terrible sheath design is a show-stopper. While I'd really like to see a lanyard hole...and I'd really like the G10 more "textured", those two deficiencies don't tip the entire show over. A little refinement will take this knife from "almost there" to "supremely superb!". I truly hope that Tops comes out with a second addition that addresses the issues mentioned in this review.