Whittling / Carving knives

For those who like to carv/whittle something. We will talk about all knife types for whittling, about types of wood and types of whittling.

If you just collect a Whittler knives, you are also invited!

Load Previous Comments
  • Jan Carter

    The mora frost looks like it is comfy in hand.  I just looked at these and am wondering it that grip looks as well thought out

    http://woodbeecarver.com/helvie-knives-viper-and-viper-ii/helvie-kn... 

  • Michael Squier

    Ron, it seems to hold an edge well. It was sharp when I got it so I left it as is and have not resharpened it yet. Its suposed to be a good laminated steel.

    Jan, those Helvies look very nice and purposful. 

  • J.J. Smith III

    Those Helvie knives sure look nice.

    One aspect that I find appropriate is the downward tilt to the blade.  One reason I favor the Seahorse Whittler is because of the downward tilt on the wharnie main blade...

  • J.J. Smith III

    Coming up in February...


  • KnifeMaker

    Robert Stadtlander

    Queen Cutlery made folding woodcarving knives for my business.  I need to find a new source so if anyone or any company is interested in providing knives, please contact me ASAP.

  • J.J. Smith III

    According to Robert's website, he's scheduled to be at the Charlotte show, this weekend.

    Type II Oar Carver?

  • Jan Carter

    OH, I hope so JJ!

  • J.J. Smith III

    I'd love to find one like yours, Jan.

    But, I'll settle for the Amber stag to go with my single locker.
  • J.J. Smith III

    Happy day, happy day.

    I picked up what's possibly the Last stagbone Version II, Oar Carver.  Had to take it off of the display itself.

    Happy day


  • In Memoriam

    D ale

    !!! .. Congrats, JJ .. !!!


  • In Memoriam

    D ale

    That Honey Amber Bone Stag is something else.

    -<not my pic .. pulled it off the net>-

    ..but..

    I've a few Queen in their Honey Amber Bone Stag. Just pulled their # 38 (split spring whittler) out of my pocket .. same scales.
    .
    Have a happy "happy day".

    DD

  • J.J. Smith III

  • J.J. Smith III

    I wasn't the only one that came in looking for one.  Fellow came up from Charleston and after I got mine he chose the Walnut.

  • Jan Carter

    oooowhee! Now that is a pretty carver!  Congrats!

  • J.J. Smith III

    I was indeed lucky, Jan.

    If I would have been 2 minutes later, it would have been gone.  

  • Jan Carter

    JJ did you get a chance to speak with Robert?  Is he having any luck finding a builder?

  • J.J. Smith III

    I did get a chance, Jan.

    I passed Dales's suggestion to check with AG Russell,  though he's not having any luck elsewhere.

    He did say someone had said that they could do one, with a commitment to buy 500, outright, and with a $5,000.00 set up fee.

  • Ron Cooper

    Comment by Ron Cooper just nowDelete Comment

    J.J,

    Knowing how you're a fan of the Seahorse, as I am, how does this beauty feel in your hand when using the big Wharnie blade? Like you, I also like the way the Seahorse blade is angled. I also like the way the Seahorse handle is tapered. 

    I suppose it's kind of an apples-oranges comparison, but how does this straight-angle, canoe-handled, Oar Carver feel compared to the off-angle, curve-tapered, Case Seahorse handle? 

    Regardless of your answer, I know those pits in your neighborhood are quivering in terror! That's certainly a right-sharp looking Queen beauty ya got there, my friend!


  • In Memoriam

    D ale

    Thanks JJ.

    .

    I also contacted A.G. Russell's firm & made them aware of the situation. I've seen similar (single-blade models) go through A.G.s inventory over the years. i.e. he already has a manufacturer tooled up & ready to go. The ramp up time might be long w/o commitments similar to those of his current quote. i.e. 500 pcs min & 5K set up fees.
    .
    Frankly .. having worked in the steel fab industry .. those are not bad terms. For instance .. fabricating an "Oar Version II" would require a minimum of 4 sets of tooling .. 1 for each blade .. 1 for the frame .. 1 for the back-spring. So the setup fee is distributed among 4 different sets of tooling operations. Further .. no one's going schedule press time ..&.. only run 100 parts. I just don't see that happening. Running the parts could take a whopping 12 minutes ..BUT.. that press-line is down for 3 hrs. Setting up the new die. Changing out the material. Setting up the material feed system. Alignment of everything as an interactive system. That's an hr & 15 minutes .. easy. Same thing on the other side .. removal of die & material & prep for a new run of .. something/anything. And .. that leaves up to 30 min run time to punch out the required blanks.
    .
    Then there's grinding & tempering of the blades .. assembly .. etc ...............
    .
    SO0oo .. 500 parts min & 5K set-up fees is really not that bad. Hopefully .. he could get some decent terms i.e. 1/3 up-fnt .. 1/3 upon completion of some pre-agreed upon production steps (often half way ..but.. define "half-way") .. the final 1/3 upon completion, delivery, & QC acceptance.

  • J.J. Smith III

    This one probably won't get much use, Ron.  I use one of the single lockers (because I have 2) and it's sweet.  If I ever get the opportunity to find another version II, I'll jump on it and give it a whirl.

    Still, the seahorse is my go to knife, for carving.

  • J.J. Smith III

    I'm sure it's not an unreasonable figure, Dale, but I'm just relaying information.

    I'm not sure what the relationship was between Stadtlander and Queen.  I do know that the Oar Carver's filled a void between Carver's that liked to carve with a pocket knife as opposed to a regular carving knife.   Flexcut knives are an option, but I simply hate them.

    It may be the "Knife Guy" in me, but they're downright ugly.

  • Jan Carter

    JJ, 

    I agree on the Flexcut, just ugly.  Hey I know where there is a 2 blade that has been used and could take a trip to SC and back !


  • In Memoriam

    D ale

    I feel the same way about certain models .. one manufacturer just excels. Others do a "good" job ..but.. one excels. I like lock-back whittlers ..but.. I've seen some ugly ones too.

    Comment by J.J. Smith III 2 minutes ago

    It may be the "Knife Guy" in me, but they're downright ugly.

  • John Bamford

    I have been meaning to buy an Oar whittler for quite some time now, I have had the Flexcut for some years and have never liked it.  As JJ say's they are ugly but to my mind, a far worse failing is that they are very uncomfortable in use. The other blades to the ones in use are always trying to make their way out of the frame and into my hand.

    Having said I have been using it for a while now as I sometimes do a little whittling in my lunch break at work. I work on my own and inhabit an old van so no-one knows what I am up to.

    No particular reason for whittling a couple of mushrooms with an oakleaf stuck to them as they emerge, just took my fancy. May get finished in another month or two of lunch breaks!

  • J.J. Smith III

    Love the mushroom carving, John.

    Sometimes it's the wood that determines the finished piece.

    The only flexcut jack, that I own, is the whittling jack.  Bought it to review.

  • John Bamford

    You are right JJ I collect a few burls that I find on trees, mostly Grey Alder around here. It isn't sensible because there tends to be so many faults inside them that Its no use planning on something just see what comes out ...if anything! 

    I only really persevere with this knife cos I paid good money for it, if I lost it then it wouldn't be replaced.

  • J.J. Smith III

    Picked up this beautiful Schatt & Morgan wharncliffe half whittler, at the Dalton show, this past weekend.

  • Ron Cooper

    Boy, that is sweet, J.J.!

    Those appear to be walnut scales topped-off with S&M's striking and unmistakeable Keystone shield...Beautiful, indeed! And a wharnie master, to boot! Yippy Skippy...Great score!

    Congrats, my friend!


  • In Memoriam

    D ale

    Schatt & Morgan

    .

    !!! .. Bet you did the happy dance .. !!!

    .

    I've a whopping 2 S&M .. my favorite being a humpback lockback whittler of their Premier series. I've a very nice leather purse for it. Still can't bring myself to carry or use it. Just .. one of those knives.
    .
    Congrats, JJ.

  • Jan Carter

  • J.J. Smith III

    I loved that, Jan.

  • Old Guy

    Very nice, Jan - thanks for sharing!

  • Chris North

    Amazing video! Thanks Jan!

  • Rome D. Rushing

    When I was growing up my mother used to tell us about when she was a little girl.

    Every christmas she would ask for a pearl handled pocket knife and she said it seemed like she got one almost every christmas.  Then just a few weeks after christmas here knife would disappear and her grandmother would tell her someone stole it.  The problem was my mother was a tom-boy and her father would get her that knife and her grandmother hated a little girl having a knife.  Momma said that after her grandmother passed away they found a half dozen knives in her dresser.

    My mother used to carve things all the time and while she was alive I gave her a new pocket knife for christmas every year.  I can remember she used to carve wooden pistols for her grandboys to play with.  And she could make a pretty good sling shot too.

  • J.J. Smith III

    Thanks for sharing, Rome.

  • Jan Carter

    Rome,

    That is a GREAT story.  I love that you gave her a knife for Christmas every year.  In my heart  of hearts I hope you have one of the pearls and one of the knives you gifted to her.  What an awesome display that would make with one of her guns or slings!


  • In Memoriam

    Kenneth W. Hill

    "HEADS UP !  Great Eastern Cutlery will be making #62 "Easy pocket carvers" soon.  These knives should be released in February.  "Cocobolo wood & natural bone" 


  • In Memoriam

    Kenneth W. Hill

  • Jan Carter

    Glad to see these in a micarta. it may help keep the cost down

  • J.J. Smith III

    aesthetically, I'm not fond of 3 wharnies on one knife, but I'm liking the natural micarta.  The muslin looks like a nice Sunday carry. 

  • Tom Peterson

    Would be nice if one of the small blades was a flat ground version of their punch blade or something similar to get in the tight spots  or even a small spey blade or rounded belly blade instead of two identical blades. They look pretty though...

  • J.J. Smith III

    Which is why I say that the Seahorse is about the ideal whittler, Tom.


  • In Memoriam

    Kenneth W. Hill

    The DLT Trading SFO #62 Easy Pocket Congress knives in snakewood (100 pieces) I just bought one and some HEAVY KPL pivot lube.   The Pocket Cavers are in production now. The GEC employees are complaining about finger cuts and the final sharping has not be completed yet. 


  • In Memoriam

    Kenneth W. Hill

    I just snagged some GEC#62 white bone "pocket carver" production photos. 


  • In Memoriam

    Kenneth W. Hill

    The Great Eastern Cutlery #62 Pocket Carvers are almost completed. 


  • In Memoriam

    Kenneth W. Hill


  • In Memoriam

    Kenneth W. Hill

  • J.J. Smith III

    I'm gonna have to go natural micarta.

  • John Bamford

    That's a terrific looking knife and would be very tempting as I am looking for a new whittling knife. The only trouble is that I have decided on a fixed blade this time.


  • In Memoriam

    Kenneth W. Hill

    Great Eastern Cutlery is producing a very short GEC#33 Conductor 1/2 whittler run.  I hear rumors that GEC is a little short on materials and they are using NOS parts to fill in the void.