Great Eastern Cutlery hosted by Ken Mundhenk

Collectors of Great Eastern, Northfield and Tidioute Knives

Load Previous Comments
  • David Adkins

    The pics look good. Too bad its built on a small frame though. A bit heftier design along the lines of the Case 55 pattern would be perfect. I'd have to have one in hand to actually comment any further. Maybe in burnt stag? Some old school popcorn handles would be good too.
  • Luca Vignelli

    Speaking of small vs. large, love  vs. loveless, I have to share my first experience with my new #23 Linerlock in Ebony I just recieved from Greg at TSA Knives.

    First of all let me admit to you that my regular EDC knife is a beauty of a Rough Rider Coal Miner Work Knife, otherwise known as a "Sod Buster" in a solid and attractive black jigged bone finish, for $12. OK, I'm a cheapo, but there's value in that knife, I would never complain. Yes, I do have a nice group of GEC knives and those didn't come cheap, and they shouldn't be either given the quality that they represent, but I don't use them every day and some I keep for special occasions (showing off), and some I keep away from dust and dirt and moisture and light, you know what I mean... Well, seeing that I'm a cheapo and that times are tough and clothing and food for my daughter, my dog, and I, are just a little bit more important, I splurged, 'cause I couldn't help myself (I tried SO hard) and I DID make an effort to save by buying an EDC knife with the "S" stamped on the tang and a minor cosmetic flaw, that you would have to be a real stickler for perfecion to notice in the first place. I did save, twenty bucks and that's a nice dinner that will take us forward one more day which I value more than most.

    Let me tell you one thing, I bought this knife with the determined intent of it being an Every Day Cary knife, so I didn't really care that it had a very very minor flaw in the finishing of the lanyard hole that Greg was direct and honest about in selling the knife, illustrating it in photos and all, which I allways appreciate. The real surprise for me is how much I absolutely friggin love this knife! 

    The #23 single blade Linerlock in whatever handle material you may prefer is a CLASSIC pocket knife that should be a part of everyone's everyday knife rotation. Not only is it just the right size, for me I have big hands and it will handle every everyday task, but it locks and has the added benefit and safety of a half-stop. The Rough Rider doesn't have a half-stop. And the GEC Tidioute #23 is not stainless 440A either but a tried and true 1095 steel. Aesthetically, I would prefer it to be all 1095 Steel, without the Nickel and the Brass, but that's just me, and maybe you too?

    Now I like a big knife, for me the #36, #46, and the #65 Ben Hogan are just the right size, though I still have to try the #12 and the and I do also have great interest in getting the #54 Moose in hand one of these days. For myself I don't really understand a knife that is smaller than 4" closed, I can't wrap my mind around it in terms of usefullness, let alone my big clumsy fingers, though they are certainly pretty (the knives not my fingers).

    OK, what's my point, you may ask?  For one, that GEC's quality standards are so superior and stringent that one should not be afraid to buy one of their "S", for "shop", or rather for savings, marked knives, "EDC", as they represent the full quality and standards of the company on a knife that one will be glad to use everyday, precisely for what it was made for.

    Knives are made to be used, daily, and without fear, and I love this single blade Ebony #23 Linerlock with all my heart.

  • Luca Vignelli

    On another note, being a "wood" man myself, I'd like to see GEC using Ebony in their Northfield line up as well as their Tidoute line. I feel that Ebony is as noble a wood as any and holds a significant place in the history of knife handles as any other wood - "black is beautiful". Go for it GEC!
  • Luca Vignelli

    Dear GEC,

    Could you please make a handle as beautiful as the one one this razor, perhaps even on the #46 or #23? Please? Pretty please with sugar on top? In Ivory, or even Acrylic, or perhaps in pure black bone or buffalo horn. Please? I'll buy two, promise. Anyone else interested?

  • Luca Vignelli

    actually the handle below would look nice on the #48 too
  • Jean-François

    Yes, I would buy at least one. Western Trapper, maybe? Luca, I MUST comment on your comments, but I'm awfully lacking of time.
  • Jan Carter

    Luca,

    Great buy on that #23.  I understand Greg just listed some new 23 EDC's.  You can also purchase EDC's right from the factory.  So is it making it into your EDC rotation or is it just too nice?  I hope you use this one.  I do believe all of Donnies users are EDC's, it is a great way to keep the cost of a knife going to a construction site lower.  The quality control at GEC is indeed very stringent, an EDC is not a second.  In the case of most EDC's (with the S for store knife) it is a small cosmetic flaw like slightly unmatched scales or a flat pin.  The perfect knife to go in the pocket with the keys and change.  Funny, we just bought my son a coal miner, I always get him one a year that wont matter cost wise if it gets misplaced and rough rider allows me to get him a knife with some quality.

     

    Good timing on that request for the rope handle.  Now that we are seeing some ivory showing up in the line up.  My vote is yes, on the 48 please 

  • Luca Vignelli

    Jan it's more than in my rotation, it hasn't left my pants pocket and I have used it to cut salami and cheese, trim some plants, open the mail, etc. Then I just sit there and admire it, rolling it over in my hands, you know the ritual...
  • Jan Carter

    Glad you found a new user that brings a smile to your face Luca
  • johnny twoshoes

    Congrats Luca, on finding a good EDC that you can really connect with, it's a special feeling knowing you have a good one. I'm gonna have to get another #23 one of these days.

     

     

  • johnny twoshoes

    Hey Robert, any chance we could catch a glimpse of a few more EDCs of your's?

    I know hunting season is upon us and our knives will be called to the field.

  • Jan Carter

    WIN A GREAT EASTERN CUTLERY PROTO!

    We will post on the Great Eastern Cutlery web site, at 2:30 p.m, Monday the 17th of October 2011, the contest details to win a #570311 Northfield Cocobolo smooth wood, PROTO etched knife.

    The first individual to respond by email to sales@greateasterncutlery.net with  all the correct answers will be the contest winner.  Distributors are excluded and only one response per contestant will be allowed.

     

  • Luca Vignelli

    Update on my enjoyment of my new #23 lockback:

    Like I have said before, I so much prefer the feel of a single blade knife as the secondary blades get in the way of a comfortable grip for me always. If I really wanted a knife with lots of blades and tools then I would get me a Swiss Army knife, call me ignorant, call me opinionated, that's how I feel and most importantly, that's how my hand feels. My new #23 single blade linerlock fits that bill to perfection, and I couldn't compliment the design of this knife and the comfort of the grip and of the half round linerlock anymore than to say it feels and is perfect.

    OK, now that I have talked about the positive aspects of this knife and of the company that I adore that produces it, let me push them to do more to satisfy their customer, namely myself, and you my friends, of course..

    Being in contact with an iKC member here from France, our dear friend Jean-Francois, I was reminded about one of the great qualities of the French knife makers, and that is that not every wonderful knife will fit your hand unless it is made to fit your hand. One of the greatest pleasures and advantages of the Laguiole or Opinel knives made in France is that they come sized, like shoes, and one has the pleasure of choosing one that fits one's person. Here in America, our knife manufacturers make a specific knife in a specific pattern of a specific size with a specific history behind it and if the shoe doesn't fit then you can't wear it. Speaking of shoes, it sound to me like that attitude, or tradition, is a great way for manufacturers to "shoot themselves in the foot", or stab themselves if you prefer... What I would like to see more manufacturers do here, and especially GEC because they are the only ones I care about, and who care about us and their future too, would be for them to introduce this European "sizing" concept to the American pocket knife marketplace. For example, a #23 single blade, whether it be linerlock or not, could be offered with a 3.5" blade, as it is now, AND a 4.5" blade and a 5.5" blade depending on your needs. It's not just about what you may have to cut, but mainly about the size of your hand - the knife should fit like a glove. The French know this well and even a cheap Opinel comes in a size #8, #9, #10, or #12, let alone the Laguioles which come in 9cm, 11cm, 12cm, and even 15cm sizes of the very same pattern. What the European manufacturers seem to have understood is that when you have a pattern that sells, and sells well consistently (my vote here in the USA would go to the GEC #23 here for starters) then you can scale it both up and down to fit your customers, and that many more sales will result in the end and for a longer, if not an indefinite, time period. It's like going custom, knife making wise, while still maintaining the economies of scale of production. Duh!

    OK, GEC, I am throwing down the glove in a challenge, can you do this for us all here worldwide, with one of your most popular patterns (perhaps the #23 as you don't have to scale it down 'cause you have the #73 there already, so it would make life easier for you), and in a single blade, which would also simplify matters for you? And since you already have a small, #73, and a Medium, #23, could you make a Large (#13?) and perhaps even and XL (#3) ??? And , of course you could do the same with other patterns too, think S, M, L, XL and beyond. Think about it, seriously.

  • Luca Vignelli

    Comments, opinions, suggestions anyone? Same argument below would go for the #12, #25 , #48 and truly so many of the other patterns. Chime in, please.
  • johnny twoshoes

    Definitely agree about the #23 and the #12. I think a smaller toothpick would make a very good EDC for the ladies. I do however, enjoy GECs commitment to bringing out new/old patterns for us. Instead of changing the ones already here, they add completely new knives to their line up. 

     

     

  • johnny twoshoes

    Well, your talking me into a #23. I'm not going to buy one for a while, but your talking me into it. I have a #73L that I love, it's still away at the factory though. There is something about getting all of that bare bone, I would love to see some more single blades. 

  • Luca Vignelli

    Johnny, I couldn't appreciate GEC's commitment to tradition more, their remaking of the all time classics has made those knives available to those of us who couldn't possibly afford the old time classics, case in point would be the #46 that I love and feel so fortunate to own. 

    As for the sizing, smaller is important, for the ladies, and kids, and larger is important for guys with big hands, and there are lots and lots of ladies, kids and guys with big hands in this world! Plenty to make it a smart business move.

    As for the #23, go for it when you can, and once you do you'll never ever look back!

    Finally, I'm glad you also appreciate the simple purity of a single blade as I do. I can only use one blade at a time, and rarely would I need a small one at that. For me it's all about the feel of the knife in your hand and secondary and tertiary blades stick into the folds of my fingers and bother me; I'd rather feel the clean lines of a well sculpted handle, which is not only a beauty to behold, but a pleasure to hold in hand. I truly believe that GEC should make all of their knife patterns that are appropriate in single bladed versions as well (for example: it wouldn't make any sense to make a Congress single blade as that would be going against the definition of the patern, but a single blade #23 or #48 or even a #25 in varying sizes and even with a choice of blade pattern would be ideal) I think that giving the customer that range of choices is something GEC, could and should, and will have to grow into as the company develops going forward. I will support them in that every step of the way!

  • johnny twoshoes

    I look forward to the release of a bigger lockback, the #72 right now seems to be about medium and it is called the Mini Lockback. So I'm guessing we have to see his big brother sometime. 

     

    I enjoy have a back up blade, but I carry multiple knives at the same time, so why not carry the one I really want to. I used #73L for a ton of chores on the farm and that knife won't back down. 

     

    I will support GECs efforts to satisfy all/any customer as they have.

  • Jan Carter

    I agree Luca, going forward it may be a smart move for GEC to allow different sizes in the pattern line up.  I do think however at this time, they are too young.  What I mean by that is, they are still building their pattern line up and bringing out more pattern options for us. I think the sizing will come with more time when we see less Permier Patterns and more variations of the existing patterns.
  • Jan Carter

    So here is the video with size comparisions for the #57...http://www.youtube.com/user/tsaknives#p/a/u/0/jjrVsii7sCc
  • johnny twoshoes

    Yes I agree, I just don't want GEC to grow up too fast though. I feel they have a great thing going right now. I kinda like the exclusiveness of GEC right now, it changes the feel about them. 

     

    I trust GEC won't fall, but I fear big business. 

  • johnny twoshoes

    I have to say, I am really jazzed about this Geppetto, I love my #56 like crazy, so I'm thinking this knife will be beast. I will own one of these knives, it's just a matter of time.

  • In Memoriam

    Robert Burris

    This is a picture of 3 of my 4 EDC Great Easterns. Two are carbon and one is stainless. The trapper in the middle was rehandled by Mr. James Ivy, in girraffe bone. The others are stag. I wait patiently for my 73 lockback to round out my four EDC's.

  • johnny twoshoes

    Thats a great picture, I really dig that #72. One of the best patterns we've seen from GEC in my opinion. Definitely some keepers my friend. I notice that these are some of the bigger GEC knives, any reason you don't carry a lil' guy?

     

    Where is your #73?


  • In Memoriam

    Robert Burris

    This size knife works best for the jobs I do with them. I am also real set in my ways and use to that size knife. There are a few smaller knifes that have caught my attention though, like that Conductor pattern.
  • johnny twoshoes

    Squirrel season tomorrow, right now I should be on cloud nine, my favorite season is here, But no, I'm still at work in my mind, thinking of all that needs done for this weeks festival. 

     

    I need some hardwoods therapy, so tomorrow if you guys need me, I'll be at the base of a big ol' oak with a GEC in my pocket and my brother by my side. I'll see if pics can't be provided too.

     

    Lets see, who should go first?

    #48 Beavertail + Remington 22.

    #56 Dogleg + Sako 22.

    #66 Mink + CZ 22.

     

    The weather decides it all, but I'm leaning towards my Beavertail. 

  • Jan Carter

    Johnny,

    We will think about you but try hard not to disturb your therapy session.  You enjoy that Beavertail my friend

  • johnny twoshoes

    So far I am enjoying it. I slipped it in the pocket this evening and I think we're ready to roll tomorrow. I really hope the weather permits good pics.
  • Jan Carter

    I am excited, my Geppetto should be here today :)
  • johnny twoshoes

    Awesome Jan, please keep us posted on it's arrival. 

    This is a pattern I want to hear a lot about, I'm not sure if it's for me yet, so I'm doing some research. I hope it's a great one Jan.

  • Jan Carter

    Here it is next to a Case Seahorse.  As we expected GEC has made this pattern their own.  It is a stouter version.  Cant want to get mine and use it
  • Jan Carter

    That one is Donnies Purple Sage, have two more on the way
  • Billy Oneale

    Great pics, Robert. Jan, Nice whittler. GEC has done another excellent job. It does look a lot stouter than the Case Seahorse. Everything is bigger.
  • Jan Carter

    Ivars,

    Thats the spirit, one of each.  The seahorse pattern is in Case's vault so it may be more difficult.  How about get a Geppetto, wait a few years for the seahorse to coem out of the vault.  If you still want one, that will be your chance

  • johnny twoshoes

    Yep, looks good Jan. I would love to here what you and Donnie have to say about this one. I'm in love with the #56 right now, it has to do with the frame I know. So, I'm looking at Geppetto.
  • Rusty R Halsey

    I've found most of the answers for GEC's contest, but a few still elude me.  Anyone know what BAL or BEJ mean?  Just kidding!  If you know the answers, enter the contest!
  • Jan Carter

    Rusty.

    ROFL, cant wait to see what gave our GEC folks here the cause to stop and think.  But we will wait until the contest is over to ask

  • johnny twoshoes

    Well, good luck to whoever wins, I can not play do to inferior knowledge. So I will sit back and root you guys on.
  • Rusty R Halsey

    The contest entry deadline has come and gone, and I still don't have all the answers.  Hopefully GEC will publish them when they announce the winner.  There were at least two I couldn't even guess at.
  • Jan Carter

    Johhny, thanks for the support...Rusty, where di you get stuck?
  • Rusty R Halsey

    HP and T were my (main) downfalls.  If H is a fixed blade Hunter and P is Punch blade, HP should be a fixed punch blade, which is an icepick (or what I get after trying to sharpen a blade) which doesn't sound right.  Maybe I'm wrong about H.  And all the T's seemed to be slimline single blade Trappers.  T for Trapper was my first thought, but there were lots of trappers without the T.  I went back and looked again and they all had lanyard holes, what some of the earlier releases called lanyard tubes.  Maybe the T is for Tube, lanyard?

    WT ... Western Trapper?  

    M - I found Muskrat, Moose, Muskrat clip blade and Mink skinner.  Which one, if any, of these is right?

    B ... Barlow?

    BAL ... Bail?

    BJ ... Big Jack?

    BJM ... Big Jack Muskrat?

    JFB ... Jack Flat Bolster?

    Yipes, the more I look at my list, the more I question what I put down.

     

  • JJ PARKER

    Rusty,

    I think HP  stands for hoof pick?  They just made a few.  I always like the Micarta one.  Jay

  • Rusty R Halsey

    Hoof Pick!  That would explain a lot.  Thanks, Jay
  • Jan Carter

    We will make sure to put a record of all of the acronyms here. JJ, hoof pick does make sense...ya'll think anyone got them ALL right?

    Johnny, just re-read your post...LOL...inferior knowledge, not a phrase I would use for your GEC knowledge

  • Jan Carter

    Cant wait to see who wins the proto
  • Bob Andrews

  • Jan Carter

    Bob,

    Thanks for the HP reference.  We appreciate it

  • Jan Carter

    Anyone notice the whats happening today?  H73311 fixed blade?
  • Tom Peterson

    Yeah Bob, Thanks for the pic of the HP 73. That clears up alot of confusion on my part. I am anxious to see who won the proto too. The HP really had me stumped for awhile!

    Jan, I like the 73 fixed blade but those muffins are looking pretty good too!

  • Tom Peterson

    The winner has been anounced! No it wasn't me :( . I won't ruin it for anyone. I did get credit for my guess at HP - hair puller! I could not figure that one out for the life of me - until someone posted it on CK's  forum and it was too late because I had already posted my entry.