Great Eastern Cutlery hosted by Ken Mundhenk

Collectors of Great Eastern, Northfield and Tidioute Knives

Load Previous Comments
  • Dana Mayo

    Hi all, I have a sunfish with a distinctive ripple on the main blade.(see pic.) I see that to one degree  or another on many of the blades. There more noticeable on high gloss blades. I call it a ripple or a wrinkle for lack of a better word. How would you describe it.

  • Dana Mayo

    David, How did you paste my earlier message onto your comment. (in italics )

  • Dana Mayo

    Jan, It's not a major issue with this knife. It's a Ben Hogan. It just seems set in there kinda low (see pic).  It even buries the nail mark a little. There's no blade to spring contact though.

  • Dana Mayo

    Jan, P.S.  I  suppose I could ask GEC to remove  a little from the top of the frame to fully expose the nail mark.  The stag is a little below the liner anyway. Evening that out would be a bonus.

  • David Adkins

    David, How did you paste my earlier message onto your comment. (in italics )

     

    Easy. Copy and paste the quote,  type your message,  highlight the part that the quote, use the blockquote button in the tool box menu above the message box.

  • Luca Vignelli

    Dana, it seems to me that you're pointing out the blade forward nail nick as being low, but on that stag model you have a foot long "long pull" just behind it, so it would seem that you have plenty of room and a choice of where you want to pull from? I have to say that for myself on the Ben Hogans I prefer the single nail nick Tidioute or the single long pull Northfields over all of the double pulls on this blade. For me it's a beautiful clean and skinny blade, and there's not enough room on the blade for a double pull without mucking it up. But hey, don't get me wrong, I'm just expressing my opinion and any criticism is directed to the design decisions made at GEC, not to you. And like I said above, it's a skinny, beautiful, and wonderfully manageable blade. The Ben Hogan model is brilliantly designed and probably has one of the best hand feels and fit of all of the GEC models, at least for my hands. Good choice.

  • Dana Mayo

    Luca, Funny you should say that as I ordered a Ben Hogan Tidioute Beaver Tail last night.

  • Dana Mayo

    High Gloss Blade

  • Dana Mayo

    Hi again, A lot of these GEC knives I have been buying don't seem to have much of an edge on them. The edges are very small. Is that due to a wide angle sharpening. I'm still a novice at sharpening. what angles do GEC use and recommend.

  • johnny twoshoes

    I believe Edge angle is for the preference of the user. I use a 25 degree angle when sharpening, but I know a lot of guys who use a 17. It really just depends on what kind of an edge you want. I am not sure how you sharpen your knives, but I use a Lanksy and I really like the job it does.

    Also, I am not sure of GECs angle when sharpening, but you could e-mail Christine Tucker, I'm sure she would know.

  • Bob Andrews

    At the GEC Factory,they put the finished edge on a knife by eye,freehand. They put a "Factory Edge" on the knife as the last step in manufacture. The Factory Edge is sharp enough to cut a sheet of paper. Individual knife owners are then free to put a lasting edge of their choice on the blade.

  • Jan Carter

    Dana,

    I know we have put alot out there for you to think about for sharpening systems and I agree with the guys.  Both those systems are wonderful.  If your looking to sharpen your own skills at it.  This video is pretty basic and easy to follow

    http://www.wonderhowto.com/how-to-sharpen-pocket-knife-307695/

  • Jan Carter

    Well it is not the newest and it is not an EDC, so I thought I would put it here.  This is the 488210EC St Patty's Day.  So happy St. Patty's Day everyone

  • Dana Mayo

    Thanks for all the help. Love that Guitar Shield.

  • johnny twoshoes

    Awesome knife Jan and happy ST. Patrick's day to you too.

  • johnny twoshoes

    Here you go!!!

  • johnny twoshoes

    I love the shields, but I'm still not sold.

    I hope you guys can get some good ones, they do look great.

  • Tom Peterson

    Jan, that's one you don't see every day! I know a collector (not me either) that is looking for one of those! Yours is a nice one! There are so many GEC's that I overlook at first and then they grow on me and by the time that I decide to get one they're long gone!

    J2S - that is a way cool shield on the #45! I've been trying to decide if these are a "gotta have it" knife or not. Will get at least one to check out anyway. It kinda stinks to have to buy all of our knives mail order and not be able to look at them and hold them before making up your mind. I just can't decide if the saw blade is a good fit or not.

  • johnny twoshoes

    Tom, you should see what Pat has to say about this knife on the GEC forum. If you do you may just end up with one. 

  • Trand

    I gotta say, I wasn't too interested in the Whaler or knives that big but I'm wanting this one. I don't have anything I need it for, but I want it :)

  • Bob Andrews

    That's the FUN part Trand, getting one when you DON'T need it at all!

  • Railsplitter

    I like it too!

  • Tom Peterson

    Johnny great minds must think alike. I just was on GEC's forum and commented on it there too. I am liking it in micarta and look forward to the other handle materials too! I does look pretty cool and I will end up with one or more but I still really want a traditional camp knife. GEC thinks out of the box alot and I like that about them but sometimes I wish they could just give us what we ask for. It's not like I'm not going to buy more knives once I get some of the ones that I really want!!!

  • Dana Mayo

    Johnny, I see that the Northfield #23 has that same half stop as the Case Back Pocket. I guess that goes along with that style.

  • Luca Vignelli

    And I hope you alos see what a much better made knife the GEC Northfield 23 is. I really hope that they reissue the 23 in spiral cut buffalo horn, that's a knife I want, anybody out there have one for me?


  • In Memoriam

    Robert Burris

    I think the big hoop la over the 66 moose is just that a bunch of bull. They may never get to it. It's sure a rare patten.

  • Dana Mayo

    Luca, what does the spiral cut buffalo look like?

  • Tom Peterson

    Luca,

    I have two #23L's but would  not  likely part with them. Planned on giving them to my two sons someday (when they plant me). I don't have good pics but here goes Dana.

  • Tom Peterson

    Robert, I hear that it IS on tap but when is a good question. I'm surprised that they didn't run them at the same time as the Calf Ropers. But the Lumberjacks are coming out soon and also CK's black delrin sodbuster SFO. Also the Wrangler and the Geppetto with a clip blade. The Wrangler looks odd and seems a bit of a waste of time, materials, energy and money to me but that is just my opinion. I don't plan on buying a single one of these. I am a bit tired of the same old frame, flipped and with the blades moved around. That's real creative....Lately I have started to question if GEC really does listen to what we want. They did make Luca's request of a single blade Whaler but that was easy enough by just removing the secondary blade. I'm curious if one were to go through all of the posts of knives that we would like to see - how many of them have come to fruition? Not enough.

  • Jan Carter

    Dana,

    I have a pic of one of the spiral's I can share with you

     

  • Jan Carter

    To the best of my knowledge there wee only 2 of these created

  • Tom Peterson

    Dana, this knife is different from the Red Spiral Cut Proto that Jan showed that was part of a raffle for the Wounded Warrior Project at the last Rendezvous. This ia a one of nine short run in black buffalo. Luca scored one of these too I believe.

  • Dana Mayo

    Tom, Jan, Thanks for great pics.

  • Tom Peterson

    Jan,

    Why did you have to post that beaut of a holy grail knife? I DID want to win that one now. I hope that the fella that won it appreciates it as much as most of the folks here would (like me for example!). I am still disappointed about not being on the receiving end of that one. The black buffalo spiral cut did help a bit but I am a bigger red buffalo fan. The Rendezvous knifes which have not been big sellers in the past went fast too to a lucky, select few.

  • Jan Carter

    Tom,

    That is truely one of the reasons we drive so far once a year.  I am a true homebody but cant pass up the oppotunity to spend time with friends and get unique knives also.  Join us this year.  We promise to share

  • Jan Carter

    Have you all seen this?

  • Jan Carter

    WOOOHOOO.  I know that some of you have asked about this recently.  The 2011 Procustion totals are published.

    http://greateasterncutlery.net/blog/information/2011-production-tot...

  • Luca Vignelli

    Ha! I like that Jan, "procustion", that's a new word I'm going to enjoy using! Love ya!

  • Luca Vignelli

    Tom, would you consider adopting me? We're the same age, but so what!

  • Jan Carter

    Luca,

    ROFL...Guess I should read it before I hit add comment

  • johnny twoshoes

    Thanks Jan, too bad I don't have any '11s. : )

  • Jan Carter

    Johnny,

    LOL, just always nice to know when your looking

  • Jan Carter

    Hey can you all check out the mock ups for 2012 knife for me.  I need material ideas.  I am leaning toward a light appaloosa.

    http://www.iknifecollector.com/forum/topics/iknife-collector-2012-c...

  • Clint Thompson

    Jan...

    How about some flash...something that snaps and jumps out at you?  Like Pearl, abalone, tiger coral or for the wood lovers Curly Maple?

  • Dana Mayo

    I like the sound of curly maple. The more exotic the better.

  • Clint Thompson

    Dana...

    Ok...exotic...mastodon tooth, maple burl...light or dark?

  • Dana Mayo

    Clint, How about birdseye and/or flame grained Briar.

  • Clint Thompson

    Dana.....

    I love the birds eye idea.  Good idea.

  • Alexander Noot

    Dyed stabilised burlwood. Blue would (wood?) look awesome I think.

    I don't think I've ever seen a slipjoint made with stabilised dyed burlwood. If blue (or maple) isn't your thing...I'm sure a different colour or wood can be selected.

    All the beauty of natural wood AND synthetics combined with none of the drawbacks of natural woods.

  • Jan Carter

    Hey did anyone notice the pics on GEC dated March 12?  Look at the last pic, does this mean a new run of new aged?