The online community of knife collectors, A Knife Family Forged in Steel
This cut out of the top part of this knife severely lowers the blade failure load, and increases deflections. Not worth it to me.
Tags:
Albums: Structural nightmere
Add a Comment
Especially so since Spyderco likes doing Full Flat grind blades. I have done this mod by request from a friend, but I did it to a Benchmade Triage and Bone collector, neither of those knives have a Full flat grind.
Charles, I believe Spyderco/Emerson (collab.) cut out this material to make a bottle opener. But in the process, they have severely compromised the blade strength. Normally there is just a hole there to facilitate opening the blade with your thumb, but someone or some people decided to cut the upper part of the "loop" away to make a bottle opener. As a result, you can just imagine just looking at it, putting more and more load on the blade would cause the blade to fail at a much lower load than if the "loop" were in place. Plus when you operate the knife normally, the blade would deflect much more easily with the cutout made. I believe the material removal was a "shoot yourself in the foot" design blunder. A lot of the blade's structural ability has been compromised by the material removal for the sake of the bottle opening feature. Not a decision I would have made.
Is there any purpose for the cutout other than just looks?
© 2024 Created by Jan Carter. Powered by
You need to be a member of iKnife Collector to add comments!
Join iKnife Collector