Welcome Home...THANK YOU FOR BEING A PART OF OUR COMMUNITY

My latest review is on a  Smoky Mountain Toothpick.  In this case the one with a stacked leather handle. 

Now you may think this knife is not a Rough Rider as the box and knife is not marked Rough Rider.  However it is cataloged at SMKW as RR626 (Rough Rider 626).

You can read the review and see more images at Rough Rider Reviews - ( blindkat.hegewisch.net/RRR/ )  or read the review below.

Rough Rider’s Smoky Mountain Toothpick (RR626)


Why I bought it:

I recently purchased the Rough Rider 626 Boot knife. As a person who likes Boot knives,  I thought this would be a nice addition to my collection of fixed blades The knife is one of many Smoky Mountain Toothpicks made by SMKW/Rough Rider. All are modeled after the old Parker Smoky Mountain Toothpick. I’m not sure what my opinion of this knife is. For the moment, I’ll say it has great untapped potential that could have been better exploited.

Dislikes.

The knife is marketed as a double-edged dagger. This isn’t the case. Neither edge is actually sharp. As I’m unsure if the steel is 420 or 440 Stainless, I’m not even  sure how well it can be sharpened . If you can sharpen it, it will take some time as the blade is quite dull. Indeed it seems to have the edge of presentation or ceremonial knife and not that of a fighting knife.

The handle is less than four inches long. It is a little difficult to grip.

The blade etch is actually a black ink pad stamping. I’m not sure how the original Parker etch was done as I’ve only seen it online and not in person. I do know the Parker stamp appeared more refined and elegant.

 

Likes:

The knife is well built and the stacked leather grip is nice and tight. The leather grip was in fact my main reason for buying this knife. The stacked leather handle reminds me of a knife designed for military/combat and I just flat out liked the way it looked.

The brass pommel and cross guard are also quite nice. The knife has great looking profile and with the exception of the dull blade makes a pretty darn good looking boot knife.

The knife is quite small and easy to conceal. It is designed to be a boot knife and could easily be used as such. In this case the small grip makes sense as the knife isn’t really designed for a prolonged fight but for last ditch defense or quick ambush at close range.

The sheath is pretty nice and fits the knife quite well. It has a large belt loop and nice belt/boot clip that appears quite sound. The handle strap is close to the throat which many people prefer. (Not my personal taste.) Leather would’ve been nicer but as sheaths go this one of the better ballistic nylon sheaths I’ve seen on an inexpensive knife.

 

Summing things up:


If you’re looking for a presentation or ceremonial boot knife, this one fits the bill quite nicely. It looks pretty good and for the price would do fine for the $10-15 price tag. The brass furniture, stainless polished and polished leather handle does make for a knife that is suited more for parade ground smartness than the take down of check-point sentry

Of course I originally bought the knife because I was looking for a sharp double edged boot dagger with the intent of using it as such, if necessary. I was hoping to make it a companion piece for my Saigon Sidekick (and I still might do this). 

I would've preferred a razor sharp blade straight from the block but this isn't the case with this knife. I could probably accomplish this with a little elbow grease but for now, I'm just going to let the knife be as it is while I ponder future projects.

 

Warning:

This knife is not a toy! Do not think for a second that it is not a lethal weapon. You could easily stab yourself or others with it if you’re not careful. I suspect the dull edge isn’t going to keep you out of trouble with the law if you’re caught carrying it in a place where you shouldn’t be carrying it. Respect it and carry it as you would any other sharp object. 

Specifications:

Name: Smoky Mountain Toothpick
Model number: RR626
Style: Boot Knife
Country of origin: China
Overall length: 8.5 inches
Overall blade length (guard to tip): 4.75 inches
Blade style: Double edge dagger
Blade steel: 440A Stainless (?)
Handle material: Stacked Leather
Tang: Full tang (Rat tail)
Handle Length (guard to pommel, inclusive): 3.75 inches
Guard: Cross guard w/ integrated blade catcher
Tang stamp:
Obverse - N/A
Reverse - China
Other identifiable marks:Blade PAD stamp with Smoky Mountain Toothpick Scroll
Pommel: Brass
Bail or lanyard: None
Sheath: Ballistic nylon w/ metal boot/belt clip

Views: 1358

Replies to This Discussion

Good review, as always!

I had a couple of the old Parker Smoky Mountain Toothpicks and the etch was a nice crisp surface etch, not real deep, but it was an etch and  filled in with black.

No doubt the lack of a sharp edge is a major drawback.   SMKW/Rough Rider should rectify this. A sharp edge makes would make this go from mediocre to really nice.  Glad I was able to give you heads up.   I'm seriously considering putting an edge on it, removing the markings and re-polishing the blade.   But first I need to verify the blade steel. I'm not going to waste my time if it 420J2 steel.

"I'm not going to waste my time if it 420J2 steel."

Yeah, but it would make a cool letter opener.

After giving this knife probably more thought, I've decided I'm leaving the blade "As is".   I hope that RR eventually releases a more functional stacked leather dagger with a sharp blade.  But this one will be a presentation style piece and possibly a letter opener. (good thought, Craig).  

I may, however, make it a new sheath.

I had the opportunity to visit the smoky mountain knife store.  I took the RR626 down to the knife sharpening section of the store.  They advised that the equipment they have was not enough to shapen this knife.  I decided not to buy it because I am not interested in so called ceremonial knifes.

What did ya'll find out about the steel?

They simply descibed as a double edge daggger blade.  This blade was clearly very thick and it would take a long time to hone it down to something that resembles an acceptable edge.
 
Robert Burris said:

What did ya'll find out about the steel?

I picked one up on eBay a few years ago.  Mine is slightly different in that its a RR037 with a black metalic handle and guard.  The sheath is the same.  IIRC, I also believe that there is at least another variant - possibly two more.  I too was disappointed in the knife, but it still has a place in my small collection.

Finally got around to do to the sheath what I wanted to do.  Here are some picsNext to my Camillus Mk2 Fighting Knife

Reverse Side

My old web belt, with an issue BOC  M7 bayonet, the RR626, Saigon Sidekick w/custom sheath adn one of my Camillus Utility knives.  I think the Tiger Stripes just adds a little something to the sheath.

RSS

White River Knives

Latest Activity

Lars Ray replied to Dennis Hibar's discussion A new iKC calendar and a new year of knives!
5 hours ago
Jan Carter left a comment for Andy Larrison
7 hours ago

KnifeMaker
Andy Larrison posted events
19 hours ago

KnifeMaker
Andy Larrison replied to Dennis Hibar's discussion A new iKC calendar and a new year of knives!
19 hours ago
Dennis Hibar replied to Dennis Hibar's discussion A new iKC calendar and a new year of knives!
23 hours ago
George R Naugle posted photos
yesterday
George R Naugle commented on Scott King's group Vintage American Knives
yesterday

Featured
dead_left_knife_guy posted a discussion
Tuesday
Jan Carter replied to dead_left_knife_guy's discussion Blade HQ has FREE SHIPPING through 4/27 or 4/28
Monday
Jan Carter commented on Michael Lee Bibbey's status
Monday
George R Naugle commented on lou gerrick's group REMINGTON KNIFE CLUB
Monday
George R Naugle commented on lou gerrick's group REMINGTON KNIFE CLUB
Monday
Carl Bradshaw commented on Jan Carter's group Daniels Family Knife Brands
Sunday
George R Naugle commented on lou gerrick's group REMINGTON KNIFE CLUB
Saturday
George R Naugle replied to Scott King's discussion What's your favorite old knife? in the group Vintage American Knives
Saturday
Kevin D replied to dead_left_knife_guy's discussion Blade HQ has FREE SHIPPING through 4/27 or 4/28
Friday

Visit Lee' s Cutlery

KNIFE AUCTIONS

KNIFE MAGAZINE!!!

tsaknives.com

JSR Sports!

Click to visit

© 2024   Created by Jan Carter.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service