"Hammer the iron that lies on your anvil instead of daydreaming about working silver. - Robert Jordan"
iKnife Collector
The online community of knife collectors, A Knife Family Forged in Steel
What is important in a knife review?
You know you see all the knife reviews on YouTube showing everything from a young kid holding a knife the whole time talking about it- all the way to a guy out hacking on trees.
I've got to ask- What makes for a good knife review?
I'm talking about more than the cinematography here- I'm talking content- meat. What are the most important points for you for the review to be a good (almost professional level) review?
I'm assuming the same points apply to a written review as is important in a vid review too, so if there's a different to you there, what is it?
Thanks for your help?
Tags: knife review
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Jan Carter on
-
Dale,
I would definatley read you reviews!!
-
In MemoriamPermalink Reply by Robert Burris on -
In my humble opinion.....Brand--history.....Type--name of design....Blade--type of steel-grind-stamping-tempering-RC vaule-shape-style-history.....Handle--material-shape-style-history....Hilt-material-shape-type....Pomell...type-shape-material....Standard Performance Test....Gossip-what others are saying about knife....Outdoors Test--Hands on-feild test...Task test[whittler-cutting wood]....MSRP...Opinion of reviewer.
-
-
Good information, hands on field tests are always interesting to me
- ‹ Previous
- 1
- 2
- Next ›
whiteriverknives.com
Latest Activity
"Putting the last finishing touches on a class III hitch receiver I installed on the wife's Outback today. Looks good!"
KnifeMakerblack mamba knives replied to black mamba knives's discussion Anyone else noticing printed "Damascus" creeping into the collectible side of the hobby?
2021 CalendarJ.J. Smith III replied to black mamba knives's discussion Anyone else noticing printed "Damascus" creeping into the collectible side of the hobby?
2021 CalendarJ.J. Smith III replied to black mamba knives's discussion Handles that keep changing after you buy them
KnifeMakerblack mamba knives replied to black mamba knives's discussion Handles that keep changing after you buy them
© 2026 Created by Jan Carter.
Powered by
