The online community of knife collectors, A Knife Family Forged in Steel
Should anyone collect Puma (Solingen made that is) as an investment?
Short answer is NO. Long answer is "Maybe", but you better know what you are buying and not presume that because it is a Solingen Made Puma that you can't lose and must make a profit over time.
Here's an example. Last week I bought a 6394 Hunter's Companion, 39 years old, in absolutely "As New" condition. The seller wanted $950, but ultimately I got it for $675. He expected that because he bought it for $500 in 1983 and had kept it, and a few other Pumas, in pristine unused condition that it was worth at least $950. The model is scarce, but not "Rare" and at an increase of only $175 over 39 years that's actually a significant loss.
Prior to around the mid 1970's Puma knives were highly regarded as premium user knives and as such were very desirable. I still have my original three that have had huge use and are way under collector condition, but they are still great knives as users.
Then Puma marketing changed and more emphasis was placed on "Investment" value, and quite successfully by what I see around.
Here's a direct quote from a 1982 Gutmann catalogue (Gutman Cutlery was the U.S.A major importer/distributor of Puma knives from 1957 to around 1990ish)
" As a PUMA collector you will feel a pride of ownership and at the same time you will have made an investment appreciating equal to or greater than precious metals" and included is a table showing what the new price of selected models was in 1957 compared to massive profits if sold in 1982 in "As New" condition.
It was a successful marketing ploy but also a load of crap
In Australia Gold was around $250/oz in 1982. Today it is around $2550/oz. If you bought a "White Hunter" in 1982 for $250, there's no chance that is is worth anything near $2550 today more like $900 tops for a perfect 6377 if you are lucky.and that's not a profit given what you can buy for one dollar today compared to 1982.
If you really know what you are buying with older Puma knives, you might make a profit on re sale, assuming that's why you buy Puma knives. eg two years ago I paid $300 for an almost mint Trapper's Companion (Left Hand Version) and that's an extremely rare knife and I've had offers of up to $2500 since but it is not for sale because that would spoil my collection.
I collect Puma knives because I like them, no other reason
If I wanted to buy a new traditional European styled hunting knife to use I likely go for a Puma IP knife, they are made by Joker in Spain under strict Solingen control and are really good quality, but I would never touch either a Puma TEC or Puma SGB although I can't blame Puma.de for turning to Chinese manufacture to stay competitive in todays market
(apology I still have more to photograph and post if anyone is interested but life keeps taking up my time)
i just got a ceramic folder with a synthetic frame . very light ,scary sharp and it looks amazing