Welcome Home...THANK YOU FOR BEING A PART OF OUR COMMUNITY

Here it is Saturday night and I'm testing out of the box knife  sharpness shearing paper - I think that I really need to get a life! lol  Anyway, tonight's little exercise was to test and report on some new Rough Riders that I have picked up recently, and as I expected, the results were not surprising at all to any of us RR fans.  The knives that I have added to the collection are:

Stroke Of Luck Large Toothpick    RR1059

Lockback with Fancy Bolster         RR182

Yellowhorse Small Sunfish             RR796

Yellowhorse Lockback                     RR800

Yellowhorse Small Toothpick       RR795

StoneWorx Small Toothpick          RR916

Smooth Bone Small Lockback       RR137

While I do realize that we are responsible as owners to maintain and sharpen our knives once we purchase them, I still feel that the sharpness of a new knife that I purchase is indicative of how much care and effort was put into it at the factory...you don't buy a brand new car and expect to have to tune it up as soon as you bring it home, do you?

That said, I used a Queen Cutlery #20 Large Toothpick with a factory edge to compare to each of the RR's paper shearing ability. To put it bluntly and in a nutshell, every one of the RR's were sharper than the Queen except for the Small Bone Lockback, and I felt that it basically tied with the Queen. And you are talking about a little RR that I picked up on the Internet for $10.00 shipped...a whole lot less than it's competition.

The Queen knife has better fit and finish and has a "walk and talk" that cracks like a whip. It has good ergonomics and feels great in the hand. It reeks of quality and is a very nice knife. But more effort had apparently put into the final stages of prepping the RR's prior to their leaving their factory, because they were sharper than the Queen, plain and simple. The "sleeper" of the night was the large blade on the Sunfish...it was a very very sharp blade. The Stroke Of Luck and the Yellowhorse Lockback were remarkably sharp also.

The Rough Rider knives are beginning to remind me of Hi-Point pistols...they do way better than they have any right to at their price point, and offer the consumer unbeatable value for the money invested. I am a believer in Rough Rider knives - period.    Steve Williams

Views: 295

Replies to This Discussion

Yea Steve, you're right about that, those Rough Riders a really sharp coming out the box. I see you stocked up on some tooth picks, would you believe I only have one tooth pick in my collection and it's a real old Case. When Queen changed over to D2 steel they began having trouble with their edge profile [just to blunt]. It takes a good while to change the profile to a slighter edge because that D2 is so hard. I hope they correct this in the future, I like Queen knives. Good luck with those Rough Riders.

These are the knives that came to me the sharpest of my recently aquired folders. From top to bottom:

Case Large Texas Toothpick  - wickedly scary sharp!

Marbles Tom Hudson Special - a solid folding hunter type knife that is way sharper than most.

CRKT Tribute 3 - a little blade play, but I like the way that it handles and does light cutting too well to sent it back!

Robert Klaas Toothpick - a whole lotta knife for not much money...I'll be checking out this brand.

RR Yellowhorse Small Sunfish - this little guy is more of a piranha than a sunfish...the big blade is sharp as a razor.

Saturday night's RR "test knives" in no particular order:

RSS

whiteriverknives.com

Latest Activity


KnifeMaker
Doug Ritter posted a discussion
yesterday
Lars posted a blog post
yesterday
David L. Packham commented on Nick Hansen's group Buck 110 Group
Monday
David L. Packham commented on Nick Hansen's group Buck 110 Group
Monday
David L. Packham replied to Doug Ritter's discussion Shocking 9th Cir. Decision Against CA 2A Switchblade Ban Appeal…NOT!
Monday
George R Naugle commented on Paul S's blog post C. F. Wolfertz Allentown Pa and Wilbert Cutlery Co Lockback Hunters
Sunday
Lars replied to Dennis Hibar's discussion A new iKC calendar and a new year of knives!
Sunday

Featured
dead_left_knife_guy replied to Doug Ritter's discussion Shocking 9th Cir. Decision Against CA 2A Switchblade Ban Appeal…NOT!
Sunday
Dennis Hibar replied to Dennis Hibar's discussion A new iKC calendar and a new year of knives!
Sunday
J.J. Smith III commented on Lars's blog post The 5-inch Folding Hunter – In a Class All Its Own
Saturday
Jack commented on Lars's blog post The 5-inch Folding Hunter – In a Class All Its Own
Saturday

KnifeMaker
Doug Ritter posted discussions
Saturday
Lars commented on Lars's blog post The 5-inch Folding Hunter – In a Class All Its Own
Saturday
George R Naugle commented on George R Naugle's blog post My first hunting knife
Friday
Jack commented on Lars's blog post The 5-inch Folding Hunter – In a Class All Its Own
Friday
Jack commented on George R Naugle's blog post My first hunting knife
Friday

© 2026   Created by Jan Carter.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service