Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Jan Carter on November 17, 2013 at 18:36

We can revisit any product they have Brad.  I am willing to talk with Ken about whatever we decide

Permalink Reply by Alexander Noot on November 18, 2013 at 3:33

Revisit? Are we giving up the hope for the Mutz knife then?

Let's hold out for a little longer and see what happends.

Permalink Reply by Jan Carter on November 18, 2013 at 4:56

not giving up yet Alexander, they are looking at 2014

Permalink Reply by jeff on November 18, 2013 at 5:13

Jan, what date are you setting as a give-up date? have you heard anythimg? at all? just wondering. it will be 5 months on the 29th for me. paid june 29th .. i think that will be my cut-off date if nothing works out. sound fair?... or are we thinking roll-over for 2014  knife? or would that be too confusing.. just thinking ahead.

Permalink Reply by Frank Stennett on November 18, 2013 at 7:12

Who are they when you say they are looking at 2014.

Jan Carter said:

not giving up yet Alexander, they are looking at 2014

Permalink Reply by Paul Slusser on November 18, 2013 at 7:50

I am with Jeff folks. I hope there is no crisis going on with Mr Mutz but I think we all deserve an honest explanation. To cut off communication is inexcusable as far as I am concerned. Everyone has been gracious about this an no one wants to put Jan in a bind but this is getting old. I could go on but I will spare you all. Lol

Permalink Reply by Tom Radde on November 18, 2013 at 9:37

peter force said:

 ... tom..i have sadly seen lots and lots of lists just like that...and for many reasons them not work.... they seem like great ideas.they always seem like they could work. ...

Hi Peter,

      I Agree and Disagree. I have seen  many lists like this fail,

and just as many succeed. (To all degrees up & down, and in the middle)

Of course this is a first, in that it, polls/questions a club knife decision, which has international

     What it all comes down to, is the people using the lists.

But, maybe people will use this, maybe not.

Maybe it will help Jan, maybe not.

Permalink Reply by Howard P Reynolds on November 18, 2013 at 14:37

I'll give it a shot, Tom:  If you hit "Reply" to my post, you can change the numbers or add more categories - just add one number to what is there.

I agree with Peter that this could get cumbersome, and adding bone color or other considerations not thought of by previous respondents would be revisited (re-posted) to "vote" on the new information, but maybe bone color, etc. could be done once a particular knife is selected.

Queen Cutlery sounds fine to me as the maker.

GEC would work if 1095 Carbon is chosen.

Don't know what the minimum order is for W.R. Case.

Tom Radde said:

 

Well, I was thinking, (I Know always a dangerous thing), anyway, how about a, ‘list’ of things wanted?

    This list, may, or may not work. But my thoughts are:
Each person, copies the below in their post, Then changes the Number, in any of the categories, or even Adds categories/sub-categories, to the list.
    (ONE number Per Person)

That way, Jan, (who I am guessing is doing all the work collecting the preferences)
will have a good idea of the majority of peoples wishes.
If you change you mind, then re-post, with the changes.
If in a category, you will accept more than one choice, PUT IN IN.
For example, you would accept,  any Bone/Wood/Antler, increase the number by one, for Each.

    Suggest, (if you all think this will work), that someone starts a new thread:
 “2014 Club Knife”.

Copy from below the line below:
   ______________________

Price of knife -
    $100.00: 2
    $200.00: 2
    $300.00:

Number of knifes made -
    50: 2
    50 - 100: 2
    100 - 200:

Type of knife -
    Camper/Scout: 2
    Fixed-Blade:  1
    Canoe:  1
    xxx:

Blade steel:

    D-2:  1

    1095 Carbon:

    440C:
Blades -
    Cutting/Style:  2

    Second small blade:  1
    Saw: 2
    Cap Lifter/flat screw driver: 2
    Corkscrew: 2

    Old-style can opener:  1
    Curved:
    Serrated:
    xxx:
Handle -
    Bone: 2
    Wood: 2
    Antler: 2
    Plastic:
    Micarta:  1

    G-10:  1
Lock -
    Yes: 2
    No: 1
Logo on -
    Blade: 1
    Handles: 2
    Both:
Liner/s -
    Brass: 2
    S.S.: 2
    Carbon Steel:

    Nickel-Silver:  1
Shield -
    Yes: 2
    No:
Length closed -
    2-3”:
    3-4”: 2
    4-5”: 

4.5"-5" - fixed-blade:  1
Style -
    Folding: 1
    Fixed blade:
Lanyard Hole -
    Yes: 1
    No:

    Bail (camp/scout knife): 1
________________________

Yea, I started !!!   LOL

Permalink Reply by Jan Carter on November 18, 2013 at 19:31

I spoke with Jeff today and he says he WILL be in this discussion tonight, I have let him know I want knives this week.  He assures me they are done.  Lets give him the last opportunity to be straight forward with us

Paul Slusser said:

I am with Jeff folks. I hope there is no crisis going on with Mr Mutz but I think we all deserve an honest explanation. To cut off communication is inexcusable as far as I am concerned. Everyone has been gracious about this an no one wants to put Jan in a bind but this is getting old. I could go on but I will spare you all. Lol

In MemoriamPermalink Reply by Terry Ray on November 18, 2013 at 20:01

I have a UPS account if shipping is the hold up?

Permalink Reply by Alexander Noot on November 19, 2013 at 8:20

Well, I'll happily wait untill the end of the week. But if there's no news by them I agree with a previous poster in that we should start thinking about letting people have their money back.

Permalink Reply by Brad T. on November 19, 2013 at 8:44

Well that is fantastic. Saves me a trip, I would not have been personable under the circumstances that might have spurred my visit. But, if he goes incommunicado again, we cut bait. These people have have waited long enough.

Jan Carter said:

I spoke with Jeff today and he says he WILL be in this discussion tonight, I have let him know I want knives this week.  He assures me they are done.  Lets give him the last opportunity to be straight forward with us

Paul Slusser said:

I am with Jeff folks. I hope there is no crisis going on with Mr Mutz but I think we all deserve an honest explanation. To cut off communication is inexcusable as far as I am concerned. Everyone has been gracious about this an no one wants to put Jan in a bind but this is getting old. I could go on but I will spare you all. Lol

• ‹ Previous
• 1
• …
• 20
• 21
• 22
• 23
• 24
• …
• 29
• Next ›
• Page