Welcome Home

I was talking with my Grandson the other day, and I told him, "I like old knives" - he said "I like the new ones".  I shared that with my wife and she said "you gotta be old to like the old things".  Maybe she is right. I find myself more and more liking older things, sayings, buildings, guns, knives, and a large assortment of older things. Seems like things made more sense (to me anyway) in the good ole days.

So when were the good ole days?? For me (I'm 67) the good ole days were in the 60's. When it comes to knives, I like a knife that was made either before I was born (1946) or at least before I graduated from High School (1964). I graduated in Arcade, New York and was surrounded by great cutleries, and didn't even think about it at the time. How many times have I driven by the Robeson factory in Perry, NY and didn't even know it.

Anyway, I like old Knives. I like all knives, but especially the older ones. Lets use this discussion to show some-of what you may think as an older knife. Looking forward to seeing a taste of "the good ole days".


Tags: Old, Robeson, Vintage, knife, knives, older

Views: 4556

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Cattaraugus Equal End Jack with Ebony handles. It has no pattern #, but the Cattaraugus stampings are on both blades. I am going to guess a date of 30's or 40's - definitely "The good ole days".

Here's my oldest..............

Martin Bros. Sheffield 1849-1854

That is one neat knife Craig, really old.. There is no one left that could remember those "good ole days".

Thanks Ken! Some days I feel like I'm that old! LOL!

I'll have to dig through mine and see what my "oldies" are and then post some here. Great subject!!

An old Imperial dating in the 1930's - Great condition with a super strong snap.

That's a nice old Jack Ken! Looks in pretty darn good shape too!

This might be my oldest knife.

A Pattern 6353/1905 knife dating from 1914. The main spear blade is the worse for wear; having been sharpened quite a bit. While the blade seems short for the frame, however, even when full bladed spear point blades in this pattern seem short. A full blade should have a 3 1/2 cutting edge from "kick to point" and be 11/16 inches wide. The blade and other metal parts shows typical pitting from a life of heavy use; possibly even a stint in the trenches of World War I. (The British issued marlin spike knives to the Army as well as Navy.  It was considered a universal tool.)

The knife’s tang marks are barely visible. While the manufacturer's name is obscured, it appears to be made by Joseph Westby. Place of manufacture is clearly shown as Sheffield.

The synthetic scales(most likely Bexoid) have a few cracks; the most noticeable being near marlin spike pins. They also show signs of shrinkage and separation from the liners. Originally the specifications called for horn handles but this requirement was quickly dropped and synthetic materials were accepted during WWI as war time expedients. After the War, synthetics continued to be used and accepted by the Navy.

The bail or "shackle" as it is described in official literature is made of 11 gauge copper wire; typical of the knives issued during WWI.  It remains in great shape with only minor scrapes and little or no greening..

Despite the wear of the main blade and other small short-comings the blade and spike opens and closes smoothly and have a good snap. The tin cutter (can opener)  is a real nail breaker to open partly due to the design of the knife and also to disuse. The tin cutter actually appears to have seen very little use. I place the knife in fair condition. Not too shabby for a military veteran that is probably over 90!

Ah......"The good ole days" - Russell Barlows .25 cents each

Camillus 4 Liners - Pre WWII - 1940's

WOW did I get a beauty in the mail today from the "Good Ole Days" - a Robeson - Straight Jack - 626636 with beautiful bone handles-kinda of an amber brown. This knife dates back from 1901-1948 - so very likely before I was born. Will post a picture in the next few days.

Just some great photos of Vintage knives!

Reply to Discussion


White River Knives

Latest Activity

Jan Carter commented on Sunil Ram's group BUCK KNIVES GROUP
1 hour ago
Jan Carter commented on Jan Carter's event 'BHK Fall Camp Out!'
3 hours ago
Jan Carter posted an event

BHK Fall Camp Out! at BHK Proving grounds

October 2, 2020 at 6pm to October 4, 2020 at 7pm
3 hours ago
Dan Lago commented on Jan Carter's group Queen Cutlery & Friends
3 hours ago
Kees ( KC ) Mension posted a status
"yes manx.... sad news indeed"
9 hours ago
Ron Cooper replied to Scott King's discussion Member Needs & Prayer Requests
13 hours ago
J.J. Smith III replied to Jan Carter's discussion A Hammer in during Covid ?!! Heck YES
14 hours ago

dead_left_knife_guy left a comment for jeff philipbar
15 hours ago
Jan Carter replied to Jan Carter's discussion A Hammer in during Covid ?!! Heck YES
18 hours ago
Jan Carter replied to Jan Carter's discussion A Hammer in during Covid ?!! Heck YES
18 hours ago
Jan Carter replied to Jan Carter's discussion A Hammer in during Covid ?!! Heck YES
18 hours ago
Jan Carter replied to Jan Carter's discussion A Hammer in during Covid ?!! Heck YES
18 hours ago
Railsplitter posted photos
18 hours ago
Jan Carter replied to Jan Carter's discussion A Hammer in during Covid ?!! Heck YES
19 hours ago
Jan Carter posted a discussion
19 hours ago
Kenneth W. Hill replied to Kenneth W. Hill's discussion 2020 GEC KNIVES IN PRODUCTION OR JUST RELEASED in the group Great Eastern Cutlery hosted by Ken Mundhenk
23 hours ago

Reed Cutlery Company

Visit Lee' s Cutlery



Maher & Grosh



JSR Sports!

gear2survive !

Click to visit

© 2020   Created by Jan Carter.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service