Welcome Home...THANK YOU FOR BEING A PART OF OUR COMMUNITY

These two knives are both carbon steel knives that see a lot of use. The top one, I have let form a nice patina and the bottom one I have not. To keep the bottom knife from forming a patina, all I do is polish it, once in a while.

  The reason for me to write this article is to show that just because you own a carbon steel knife, you don't have to have one with a patina. I enjoy my carbon steel knives both ways and you can too, with a little care. Those that believe a shinny blade can only be had with stainless steel are wrong. Please enjoy your carbon steel blades either way, with or without a patina. Tell me what you think about this subject.

Views: 508

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of iKnife Collector to add comments!

Join iKnife Collector

Comment by David Selph on February 6, 2014 at 16:43

I would guess that some folks who keep their blades nice and shiny (nothing wrong with that) really wouldn't mind a fully developed patina.  I must admit that the appearance of the blade while it is developing a full natural patina could be disturbing to some.  A natural patina takes time and patience to properly develop while keeping the knife properly maintained and oiled.

Comment by John McDowell on February 6, 2014 at 11:42

it seems crazy but mustard is a great way to force a patina,only takes about 20 min.


In Memoriam
Comment by Robert Burris on February 5, 2014 at 18:57

Hey guys and gals, I first want to thank all of you for enjoying and discussing my topic on knives with or without a patina.

  This is a great topic, because so many of our knives are made with carbon steel. Love it or hate it, it's a great knife steel. I think as knife users and collectors, this is a very important subject for us to discuss. Especially, for those of us that are not educated about it's character.

  Ya'll please enjoy the topic and not make a division between the Carbon steel and Stainless steel enthusiast.   

Comment by David Selph on February 5, 2014 at 17:04

I like patina.  I wish all my blades on all my knives was 1095.  I believe there is some minor protection from surface rust with a patina but I would never trust it as a substitute for a good routine of wiping the blade after use (rinse as necessary) and keeping a very thin film of oil on the blade.  I use my EDC's to cut apples and such so I use a very light coating of mineral oil on all my 1095's.  Worked well so far.


Featured
Comment by Craig Henry on February 5, 2014 at 16:39

I've read that too JJ about a patina helping to keep a blade from rusting. I don't know myself since I always polish my carbon steel before it can do anything. LOL! 


2021 Calendar
Comment by J.J. Smith III on February 5, 2014 at 1:46
There are plenty of discussions on the internet about patina on knives. Most, if not all, indicate that a patina will protect blades better than no patina.
Steve said that a patina indicated a working knife. I'll agree.
If you want a collector knife, keep it shiny. If you're going to use it and not rely on collector value, a patina is acceptable.
Comment by Alexander Noot on February 5, 2014 at 1:25

Whilst I'm out on a trip a Patina doesn't bother me. Usually when I get home though I'll polish it off.


Featured
Comment by Craig Henry on February 4, 2014 at 23:56

Shoot, I think I'M getting a patina!


In Memoriam
Comment by John McCain on February 4, 2014 at 22:08

IMHO- it depends on the "character" of the knife which is only in the eye of the collector/owner- I have seen "forced" patinas using mustard or the old uric acid (piss)  patinas that looked awesome on some new knives and horrible on others. I say, if it is appropriate to the knife and gives it character, leave it be - If you feel it detracts from the knife, shine away !! I have done both myself, let the patina do what is was meant to do, and on others   felt it necessary to do a little polishing!!

  


2021 Calendar
Comment by J.J. Smith III on February 4, 2014 at 21:16

whiteriverknives.com

Latest Activity

Lars commented on Kevin D's photo
2 hours ago
Lars commented on Kevin D's photo
2 hours ago
Kevin D commented on Kevin D's photo
5 hours ago
Kevin D commented on Kevin D's photo
5 hours ago
Lars commented on dead_left_knife_guy's photo
yesterday

Featured
dead_left_knife_guy posted photos
yesterday
Jan Carter replied to Jan Carter's discussion 2027 iKC Calendar in the group iKnifecollector GEAR
Saturday
Carl Bradshaw commented on Jan Carter's group Daniels Family Knife Brands
Saturday
Lars replied to Jan Carter's discussion 2027 iKC Calendar in the group iKnifecollector GEAR
Saturday

Featured
dead_left_knife_guy replied to Jan Carter's discussion 2027 iKC Calendar in the group iKnifecollector GEAR
Saturday
A discussion started by Jan Carter was featured
Saturday
Jan Carter replied to Jan Carter's discussion 2027 iKC Calendar in the group iKnifecollector GEAR
Saturday
Jan Carter replied to Jan Carter's discussion 2027 iKC Calendar in the group iKnifecollector GEAR
Saturday
Jan Carter added a discussion to the group iKnifecollector GEAR
Saturday
Kevin D commented on Jan Carter's event 'Kentucky Knife Exposition Shepherdsville'
Saturday
Kevin D might attend Jan Carter's event

Kentucky Knife Exposition Shepherdsville at Kentucky Knife Exposition Shepherdsville

March 18, 2027 at 6pm to March 19, 2027 at 7pm
Saturday

© 2026   Created by Jan Carter.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service