Welcome Home...THANK YOU FOR BEING A PART OF OUR COMMUNITY

I got this Colonial melon tester knife off of eBay for $17 with shipping.  It is in pristine condition with very good snap, not a blemish on it.  Even though it appears to never have been used, carried, or sharpened, it is hair shaving sharp.  It has brass liners with a brass bird's eye pin.  Overall it appears to be a good quality knife.  But what attracted me to it is what is on the handles.  Since it says "Compliments of" I assume that it was some sort of give away or promotion item obviously associated in some way with SMKW.  I have posted it on Steve Paolantonio's Facebook page in hopes that he can tell me the story behind the knife.  I like knives with a story behind them.  It will make a good addition to my Colonial collection.

Views: 703

Replies to This Discussion

Great score, Charles! Especially in this beautiful condition! Use it in good health, my friend.

Thanks Ron.

This is an amazing find in this condition, the writing is not even faded!  Goodness I hope Steve has the story I would love to hear about it

Jan, I sure hope Steve can tell me the story.  There obviously is one and it involves both Colonial and SMKW.  The writing is what made me want this knife.  I already had one ordinary Colonial melon tester in pretty good shape but not pristine like this one.

RSS

whiteriverknives.com

Latest Activity


Featured
dead_left_knife_guy commented on Kevin D's status
yesterday
Kevin D posted a status
"Ever heard of Eafengrow? Looking forward to a EF159 delivered Saturday."
Wednesday
George R Naugle replied to Jan Carter's discussion PUMA Collectors in the group BOX FULL OF KNIVES
Tuesday
George R Naugle posted a photo
Tuesday
Lars commented on Mike Bryant's photo
Monday
Mike Bryant posted photos
Monday
George R Naugle commented on George R Naugle's status
Monday
J.J. Smith III left a comment for James Kastorff
Sunday
James Kastorff is now a member of iKnife Collector
Sunday
George R Naugle posted a status
"12 degrees here in downtown Saint Thomas, PA this morning. The wind has died down, so it is no longer a brutal day."
Sunday
George R Naugle commented on Kevin D's blog post A Problem With Fakes
Sunday

Featured
dead_left_knife_guy posted a discussion
Feb 7
George R Naugle posted a status
"14 degrees and 30-40 mph winds today. A good time to work on organizing my collection."
Feb 7
Kevin D commented on George R Naugle's status
Feb 6
George R Naugle commented on George R Naugle's status
Feb 6
Kevin D commented on George R Naugle's status
Feb 6

© 2026   Created by Jan Carter.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service