Welcome Home...THANK YOU FOR BEING A PART OF OUR COMMUNITY

Sometimes burrs are large and easily identified.  Sometimes they are very small and harder to detect but big enough to make the knife cut poorly.  Some ways find large burrs but don't detect small burrs.  Since I learned of different ways to identify a burr over time there may be other ways that I'm unaware of that some of you already know.  I'd like to know as many ways to detect a burr as possible.  Maybe some of you feel the same.  If we list our burr detection methods it may make us all more knowledgable.  So I'll list the methods I use or am aware of and invite anyone else to list their's.

These are the two methods I use most often.

1. Slide meat of my thumb or finger down the side of the edge bevel.  Or I'll use my thumbnail which is a little more sensited to burrs I think.

2. If I strop where there is a burr the burr will roughen the leather.  An edge with no burr doesn't scratch the leather or whatevery the strop is made of.  This has shown me I have a burr many times that I was not detecting with my thumb or thumb nail.  If I detect a burr this way I go back to the stone to remove it and then strop again.  I don't like to use strops to remove burrs.  That should be done on the stone.  The strop is an edge refining tool in my opinion, not a burr removing tool.  However, a strop when used properly can be a burr removal tool.  Just as long as the burr is REMOVED and not straightened.  Straightening a burr makes the edge feel sharp but the steel is weak and the straightened burr will break off easily during use leaving a duller spot on the edge.

I have also heard of using a cotton ball to slide off the edge to see if a burr catches strands in the cotton ball.  This may be good for people who don't have as much feeling in the fingers.

I think burrs are the biggest problem we have when sharpening a knife so detecting them is essential.  Does anyone have other ways to find your burrs?  I would appreciated knowing different methods and maybe other's would also.

Jack

Views: 522

Replies to This Discussion

I like the idea of a cotton ball as I have little or no finger feeling, so that might help at least seeing it snag along the way. Can you magnify the edge to try and see where the burrs are?  I guess though you still would need to mark it in some way?

You can see burrs on magnified edges.  I have on my Christmas wish list a microscope (http://www.chefknivestogo.com/vedeusbpomi.html) to view edges.  I have wanted something like this for a while but just couldn't justify the money.  Now that my grandson is getting older I'm betting he could use something like this for school.  Science class to look at bugs and stuff.  See how I use my grandson to justify buying stuff for my knife/sharpening hobby?  Pretty clever huh?  lol

Steve Hanner said:

I like the idea of a cotton ball as I have little or no finger feeling, so that might help at least seeing it snag along the way. Can you magnify the edge to try and see where the burrs are?  I guess though you still would need to mark it in some way?

I think you can also see the burrs with smaller loupes.  I have one with a 30x and a 60x lens on it.  I'm gonna try to use it to  look for burrs with it next time I sharpen.  So far I just used it to look at scratch patterns.  The thing about high magnification is I can be looking at my very beautiful mirror finish and feeling proud.  Then I magnify the edge and depression sets in.  WHERE DID ALL THOSE SCRATCHES COME FROM?!!!.  LOL

RSS

White River Knives

Latest Activity

Lars Ray commented on Lars Ray's blog post Sentimental Attachment
8 hours ago
Lars Ray commented on Kevin D's status
9 hours ago
Lars Ray posted a status
"Happy Anniversary Kevin & Jade! Wishing you all the best in your next 28 years :-D"
9 hours ago
Kevin D posted a status
"Twenty-eight years ago today, my lovely wife joined me in matrimony. As Ronnie Milsap sang, "I Wouldn't Have Missed It For the World"."
9 hours ago
Kevin D commented on Lars Ray's blog post Sentimental Attachment
9 hours ago
Christian Lemasson left a comment for Lars Ray
15 hours ago
Lars Ray posted a blog post
16 hours ago
jack walker replied to Dennis Hibar's discussion A new iKC calendar and a new year of knives!
17 hours ago
Lars Ray left a comment for Christian Lemasson
20 hours ago
J.J. Smith III left a comment for Christian Lemasson
yesterday
Christian Lemasson is now a member of iKnife Collector
yesterday
J.J. Smith III left a comment for Luke Leissner
Thursday
J.J. Smith III left a comment for Michael Pierce
Thursday

KnifeMaker
Doug Ritter posted discussions
Thursday
Lars Ray left a comment for Michael Pierce
Thursday
Lars Ray left a comment for Luke Leissner
Thursday

© 2025   Created by Jan Carter.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service