A Pakistan suppliers point of view...didn't see that coming did you?

I was recently contacted by a supplier of Pakistan knives and steel.  Now, Now...give this discussion a chance.

This supplier has been on iKC for a number of years.  When he first contacted me it was with the hope that I would listen and have an open minded discussion with him.  Because he is a member and has been very respectful not to overstep here at iKC with selling openly.  I chose to listen.  This was how the discussion started

The issue is that I want to directly market my knives in USA market, these have already been sold in large quantity but indirectly by my country men, both in retail and wholesale. But I am sick and tired by their behavior of exploiting the smooth running business contact by dishonesty in many ways.

Well, that intrigued me & I decided to be brutally honest.  My reply was that you face 2 challenges.  Poor steel reputation from the region and the working environment (as we know it).  A few more emails passed regarding the environment of the workers.  We came to understand that he himself is not a maker, but has many local makers producing for him.  He interviews makers before he begins to accept their work and checks out their product.   My next question?  Do you employ kids?  The answer, yes.  It is a fact of the economic life in that region that children work within the family.  Much the same as it was for us many, many moons ago.  What did I find different enough to continue listening after that statement?  He discusses with the family before hiring a young worker that he wants them them to get an education also.

So my next discussion with him focused solely on quality, not of the build but of the steel.  I asked him to read a current discussion on here http://www.iknifecollector.com/forum/topics/does-anybody-want-this-....  I have been pretty brutally honest with my answers to him.  I advised him to give a few of his knives to people that use them hard and have them reviewed.  I also advised that he needed to be prepared for the response about the knives be that whatever it may be!

Lat me start by making this clear.  I do not intend to sell Pakistan knives, nor will I allow soliciting on the site.  As an international community I am curious.

So here is my question.  If you knew a company stood behind their product, that you were dealing with the company owner.  Would YOU be willing to buy a knife made in Pakistan?

Views: 559

Tags: Forum, Knife, Pakistan

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of iKnife Collector to add comments!

Join iKnife Collector

Comment by Jan Carter on July 19, 2014 at 20:04


Great reply and what I want.  Honesty.  I myself am not a pakistan buyer but I have to say the business practices and the discussion made me think.  Your list looks almost identical to mine and to my end of the discussion

Comment by Charles Sample on July 19, 2014 at 18:51

Yes, I would be if:

-there was quality commensurate with the price

-they would stand behind their product

-they were honest

-they would specify the type steel

-the factory owner isn't getting filthy rich while the employees are still in abject poverty.

Those are some of the ifs.  They should give an idea of what I would expect.  But I would have to say I would not expect to buy many Pakistan knives.  I would prefer to buy all American made knives as well as anything else I buy.  However, that is nearly impossible to do in this day and time.

I do have several knives made in Pakistan.  And at least two of them I did buy myself.  However that was in my accumulator days before I became what I consider a serious collector.  I do still buy foreign made knives but they are almost all Rough Riders.  And that points to the quality factor, they are inexpensive knives but give good quality for the money.

The last two other than RR foreign made knives I bought were a Chinese made Buck and a Kissing Crane.  But there was something about both of those knives that made me want those specific knives.  For the most part it would probably have to be something like that to get me to buy Pakistan knives.

So to answer your question, yes.  Under the right conditions I would buy a Pakistan knife.

White River Knives

Latest Activity

J.J. Smith III commented on J.J. Smith III's status
24 minutes ago
J.J. Smith III commented on Jan Carter's event 'SMKW Rep Weekend-**TN**'
26 minutes ago
Jan Carter posted a status
"Good Night and God Bless all"
1 hour ago
Jan Carter commented on J.J. Smith III's status
2 hours ago
Jan Carter commented on Jan Carter's event 'SMKW Rep Weekend-**TN**'
2 hours ago
J.J. Smith III posted a status
"Perhaps all the criticism of eBay has paid off. Somehow I just won another Rough Rider RR323"
2 hours ago
Jan Carter replied to Bryan W's discussion The Lehigh Valley Knife Show of Easton, PA - September 28 & 29 - Back on Track!
6 hours ago
John Kellogg left a comment for Glenn Bright
7 hours ago
D ale commented on Glenn Bright's photo
13 hours ago
Glenn Bright posted photos
22 hours ago
Glenn Bright joined Michael D Sabol's group
23 hours ago
Bryan W posted a discussion
Bryan W commented on Jan Carter's event 'LEHIGH VALLEY KNIFE SHOW**PA**'
Bryan W commented on Jan Carter's event 'LEHIGH VALLEY KNIFE SHOW**PA**'
Bryan W is attending Jan Carter's event

LEHIGH VALLEY KNIFE SHOW**PA** at Charles Chrin Community Center of Palmer Township

September 28, 2019 at 6pm to September 29, 2019 at 7pm
Charles Campagna left a comment for Jan Carter

Reed Cutlery Company

Visit Lee' s Cutlery

gear2survive !





JSR Sports!

Click to visit

© 2019   Created by Jan Carter.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service